A bodhisattva-spirit-oriented counselling framework: inspired by Vimalakīrti wisdom
© Cheng and Tse; licensee Springer. 2014
Received: 5 June 2014
Accepted: 18 August 2014
Published: 25 September 2014
A number of studies have integrated Buddhist principles into therapeutic interventions, demonstrating effective outcomes; however, very little Buddhist textual data support the theoretical foundation of those models. This exploratory research conceptualises a counselling framework based on a canonical analysis of the Vimalakīrti Nirdeśa Sūtra, together with a qualitative inquiry. Thirty-eight informants, including helping service practitioners, Buddhist masters, Buddhist volunteers, and beneficiaries, were recruited through cold calls, social networks, referrals, and electronic mail. Forty-six semi-structured interview sessions, involving individuals and focus groups, were conducted in the form of face-to-face discussions, telecommunication, and correspondence. Data collection was performed using multiple sources, consisting of interviews, expressive art, and autobiographies. Both scriptural and fieldwork data were analysed with the aid of ATLAS.ti 7, a software package; while interview data were processed under phenomenological interpretative analysis. Different levels of triangulation were employed to enhance the research rigour, including member-checking of transcriptions and data interpretation, and peer analysis, with an inter-rated reliability of 92%. This bodhisattva-spirit-oriented counselling framework was then finalised with two super-ordinate themes (philosophical concepts and propositions for counselling), 14 emergent themes, and 40 themes. This counselling framework, from the prajñā perspective, not only exhibits Mahāyāna wisdom, but also revitalises the practicality and applicability of catvāri apramānāni (the four immeasurables) in today’s contemporary context, approving the aspiration of the Buddha to serve sentient beings.
KeywordsBodhisattva-mārga Catvāri apramānāni Cross-disciplinary research Expressive art Mixed method Qualitative fieldwork Self-benefiting altruism Vimalakīrti Nirdeśa Sūtra
Western scholars have increasingly been interested in Buddhism since the 17th century (Conze ), and particularly after the Second World War (Gethin ). Through the influence of their studies, Buddhism has expanded to not only religion circles, but also science (Kaklauskas and Olson ), art, social studies (Jones ), and psychology (Storhoff and Whalen-Bridge , Loy , Hsing-Yun ). Buddhism has been characterised as an “edifying philosophy” (Watson , 14), and a “dialectical pragmatism with a psychological turn” (Conze , 15). For instance, both catvāri-ārya-satyāni (the four noble truths 四聖諦), alluding to “the disease, the cause, the cure, and the medicine” (Gethin , 59), and Chan (Zen 禪) meditation have been considered as healing methods (Kief ) to dissolve mental challenges (Sugamura and Warren ). Interfacing one of the world’s oldest religions (namely, Buddhism) with a relatively new discipline (psychology) (Bankart, Dockett, and Dudley-Grant ), intellectuals have continuously explored the similarities between these two domains (Kaklauskas et al. ). Having experienced these valuable Buddhist resources as “an ethical consciousness suitable for the global culture of the 21st century” (Wright , 15), professionals have integrated Buddhist ideas into helping or caring professions (Walley , Fielding and Llewelyn , Welwood , Heelas and Kohn , Claxton ), including social work (Brandon [1976/1990], Canda and Furman ), and psychotherapy (Fromm ); for example, de Silva (), Epstein (), Goleman (), Kabat-Zinn (), Rubin (), Suzuki, Fromm, and DeMartino (), Wallace and Shapiro (), and Young-Eisendrath (). Supported by voluminous research projects, this “New Buddhist Psychology” (Kwee, Gergen, and Koshikawa , 22; Kwee and Taams , 435), as part of “Buddhist modernism” (Deeg , 376), has developed a “brand of psychotherapy” (Ponce , 331) centred around remedial and preventive measures tackling psychological disorders and life challenges, particularly by means of meditation and mindfulness (de Silva , Kabat-Zinn , , Crane and Kuyken , Gehart , Teasdale, Segal, and Williams , Thompson and Waltz ), attaining “the path of happiness” (Inoue , 89). Focusing on the idea of “spirit-in-pouch, pouch-in-spirit, or body and mind as one” (Akizuki , 115), this approach differs from Western traditions.
While the ultimate goal of “human-centred” (Guruge , 62) Buddhism is to enable sentient beings to eradicate suffering (de Witt , Long ) and achieve happiness (Rahula ), Buddhist masters play a conventional role in helping laity cope with life adversities and psychological difficulties (Dhammanaha ) through Buddhist practices, such as through using “mind training” (Thubten , 32), and “thought transformation” (Thubten , 32) to calm down an unquiet mind (Bankart, Dockett, and Dudley-Grant ). The mind collectively involves the “holistic feeling, judgements, prejudices, and bigotries, as well as the ability (or inability) to accurately take the feeling temperature of a social situation, physical space, or aesthetic presentation in one experience” (Walker , 184), or otherwise simply termed “emotional intelligence” (Goleman , ix; , 7–10, 375–376). Within mind training, Buddhist masters, acting like counsellors, facilitate followers to possess a pure and crystal clear mind and to gain insight reflexively (Claxton ). Subsequently, sentient beings are able to convert suffering into motivation for personal growth (Hoffman ) and further self-exploration (Epstein ), which echoes with the Vimalakīrti teachings that are applied to the philosophical theories in this cross-disciplinary study integrating Buddhist resources into counselling. The Vimalakīrti Nirdeśa Sūtra (維摩詰所說經), an influential Mahāyāna canon, elaborates on the concepts of bodhisattva and bodhisattva-mārga (the bodhisattva path 菩薩道), hinting at propositions of counselling.
By honing in on the Buddhist focus on praxis (Kasulis ), rather than comparing it with Western psychotherapeutic approaches, the present research conceptualises a bodhisattva-spirit-oriented counselling framework for applying to a generic therapeutic context, wherein the practice of bodhisattva (菩薩) represents the core Mahāyāna (Great Vehicle 大乘佛教) theory (Kanbayashi /), in which the mission of a bodhisattva is to free living beings from suffering. This is compatible with the goal of helping professionals, such as counsellors, psychiatrists, and clinical psychologists. The present study applies the teaching of catvāri apramānāni (the four immeasurables 四無量心) to therapeutic settings because this notion offers a roadmap for how to practise bodhisattva-mārga (the bodhisattva path 菩薩道) in a way that inspires counselling theories and practices. This research has adopted a mixed research method, employing a canonical analysis of the Vimalakīrti Nirdeśa Sūtra (維摩詰所說經) and qualitative interviews, so that it supplies primary data to strengthen the theoretical foundation for the available Buddhist-influenced interventions, especially in humanistic approaches (Watson ). Supported by the Buddhist traditional hierarchy of “theoretical considerations, methodological considerations, goals and implications” (Watson , 19), this counselling framework consists of philosophical concepts and propositions for counselling that are elaborated upon respectively. The former includes views of human nature, worldviews, life views, and the bodhisattva spirit; whereas the latter covers therapeutic mission and goals, roles and qualities of a counsellor, case conceptualisation, therapeutic relationship, therapeutic strategies and tactics, skills, and techniques.
The conceptualisation of a counselling framework in this research, grounded on a Buddhist canon (discussing its practicality from a secular perspective), and qualitative fieldwork represents an exploratory inquiry, which not only offers doctrinal data and extends the horizons of Buddhism as applied to mental well-being, but also attempts to make this mixed method available for counselling research. Further discussion is invited for the purpose of enhancing the development of these approaches.
2.1 Research design
This cross-disciplinary research, while focusing on first-hand data, adopts a mixed method, mingling canonical analysis with qualitative study, from which the former provides textual evidence giving direct voice to a Buddhist text while the latter represents the lived experiences of interviewees, supporting the applicability and practicality of Buddhist teachings in modern society.
2.2 A canonical analysis
The Vimalakīrti Nirdeśa Sūtra (維摩詰所說經) (hereafter called the Sūtra), written from sometime in the late first century to the early second century A.D. (Lin a), is one of the prominent Mahāyāna canons (Zheng 1986) explicating prajñā (wisdom 般若) (Kaziyama 1994). The details describes regarding the major Mahāyāna teachings, especially madhyamaka (the Middle School 中觀) (Lamotte 1976/1990), significantly affect other schools of Buddhism, including Chan (Zen 禪宗) (Sheng-yen  and Suzuki /[1981a]), Tiantai (天臺宗) (You ), and Vajrayāna (Tantric Buddhism 密宗) (Tam ), positively impact the culture of the upper and lower Chinese social classes (Mather , He ). Its influence also extends to other countries, such as Vietnam (Lieu ), Japan (Zheng ), and Korea (Miller ).
Vimalakīrti, the protagonist of the Sūtra, is a “household bodhisattva” (Lopez and Rockefeller , 28), practising bodhisattva-mārga (the bodhisattva path 菩薩道) in the loka (the secular world 世間). This Sūtra, designated thus by the Buddha, is named after himi, which is rare in Buddhist traditions. This symbolises the importance of Buddhist laymen who are devoted to practising Buddhist teachings in their daily life in the development of Mahāyāna (Yin-Shun ). This is particularly true in the case of self-benefiting altruism contributing to society, such as the helping or caring professions (for example, counselling, nursing, social work, occupational therapy, and education).
2.3 Qualitative inquiry
In this qualitative fieldwork, which was approved by the Human Research Ethics Committee for Non-Clinical Faculties, The University of Hong Kong, 38 participants in “purposeful sampling” (Patton , 46) were recruited for this exploratory study. Demographic information for the participants is broken down into the following areas: gender (n=25 female, 65.8%; n=13 male, 34.2%), age (n=3 aged 18-30, 3.9%; n=12 aged 31–45, 31.6%; n=20 aged 46–60, 52.6%; n=3 aged over 60, 3%), and education (n=1 primary school, 2.6%; n=6 secondary school, 15.8%; n=8 undergraduate, 21.1%; n=15 postgraduate, 39.5%; n=8 doctoral degree, 21.1%).
Demographic synopsis of the participants
Categories of participants
Beneficiaries (n=9; 23.7%)
Buddhist masters (n=11; 28.9%)
Buddhist volunteers (n=6; 15.8%)
Helping service practitioners (n=12; 31.6%)
Social networks (n=10; 26.3%)
Cold calls (n=15; 39.5%)
Electronic mails (n=7; 18.4%)
Facebook page (n=0; 0%)
Referrals and snowball effects (n=6; 15.8%)
Helping service practitioners
Clinical psychologist (n=1; 8.3%)
Counsellor (n=3; 25%)
Psychiatrist (n=3; 25%)
Social worker (n=1; 8.3%)
Teacher (n=4; 33.4%)
Selected in-text citations
Amara, Che Wai, Chi Sim, Esther, Dun Li, Pema Kazhuo, Pureté de Lotus
Rinpoche K*, Venerable Chi Yiu, Venerable Foo Chai, Venerable Sander, Venerable Thong Hong, Venerable Yu Chun, VHU*, VHY*
Betty, Yim Na
Helping service providers:
Dr Chan (a helping service practitioner), Dr Li (a psychiatrist), HW* (a helping service practitioner), Jackie (a social worker), JC* (a psychiatrist), Joe (a counsellor), KJ* (a psychiatrist), LP* (a counsellor), ML* (a counsellor), Polly (a clinical psychologist)
Forty-six semi-structured interview sessions (44 sessions with individuals, and two with focus groups), totalling 2,729 minutes, were conducted with the aid of guiding questions from March 2011 to October 2012, by means of face-to-face interviews in Hong Kong, telecommunication methods, or other correspondence. The two Buddhist volunteer focus groups not only shared their personal ideas, but also served as a means of triangulating the experiences of other individual informants.
Analysis themes of the bodhisattva-spirit-oriented counselling framework
Views of human nature
● Nature essentials
● Nurture properties
● Du ḥ kha
● The other shore
The bodhisattva spirit
● Catvāri apramānāni
Propositions for counselling
● Free from suffering
● Rejuvenation of bodhi nature
Roles of a counsellor
● A metaphorical doctor
● A facilitator
Qualities of a counsellor
● Bodhisattvsa-bodhisattva interplay
● Rejuvenation of purity and awareness
● Removal of kleśa, avidyā, and moha
● Transcendence of kleśa
● Gratitude for suffering
● Role Model
2.4 Philosophical concepts
The philosophical basis of this counselling framework involves views of human nature, worldviews, life views, and the bodhisattva spirit from the perspective of prajñā (wisdom 般若) in Mahāyāna. It potentially offers a theoretical ground for propositions for counselling that reflect the applicability and practicality of these teachings.
2.5 Views of human nature
The school of prajñā (wisdom 般若) views human nature from the dimensions of nature and nurture, associated with inward and outward factors, using the metaphor of a dusty mirror.
2.6 Nature essentials
Regarding the nature aspect, the school of prajñā (wisdom 般若) treasures the immaculacy and innocence of human nature; however, it also acknowledges an imperfect environment that causes defects in sentient beings. And yet, sentient beings are anātman (non-self 無我), and are in a changing state, implying the possibility of restoring their bodhi nature.
2.7 Bodhi nature
The prajñā (wisdom 般若) school values the inherent chastity of human natureii that leads sentient beings to awaken (Yamaguchi [1999/2006]), referred to as the bodhi natureiii, tathatā (suchness 真如), a pure mind (Zheng ), or the “Buddha-nature” (Abe , 20); that inner force in which is able to dissipate delusion and attain one’s authentic self (Reichenbach ). Since the human nature is identicaliv across individuals, without divergencev, both ‘angels’ and ‘devils’vi can potentially be enlightenedvii. Based on the belief that “every person innately possesses the buddha nature,” Dr Li (a psychiatrist) concurred with Buddhism, that sentient beings have a high tendency towards self-actualisation, which establishes an essential rapport for counselling practitioners. This gives heart to the goals and strategies of counselling to energise the purity of human nature and achieve “brilliant sanity” (Townsend and Kaklauskas , 47).
2.8 Anātman(non-self 無我)
Sentient beings are all identically living under pratītya-samutpāda (the law of dependent origination 緣起法), forming stages of birth, growth, deterioration, and death due to the combination of hetu (necessary causes 主因) and saha-kāri-pratyayaviii (contributing causes 助緣), which produces changes and uncertainties. Thus, sentient beings as such, as well as these two types of causes, are delusive representations without fixed formsix, like clouds, foam, or bubblesx. In Buddhism, this concept of self is associated with anātman (non-self 無我), an interdependent self (Wright  and Dow ), explaining the transient physical, mental, and psychological states of human beings. Both the growth and ageing of individuals represent the temporality of the physical domain, while the mental and psychological states also change from time to time, being affected by physiological and emotional factors. These inescapable encounters cause the self to be unreal (not in a fixed form or state) (Zheng ).
Despite these challenges, sentient beings, with their bodhi nature, are capable of conquering their vexations and transcend anitya (impermanence 無常) (Soothill ) through “self-cultivation” (Wright , 3), self re-enlightenment, and “self-transformation” (Wright , 12), resulting in re-discovery of their “original self” (Akizuki , 116). This optimistic proposition in Buddhism related to human nature encourages individuals to experience “emptiness of self” (Kornfield , 76) and to make the best use of self.
Inspired by prajñā (wisdom 般若) teachings, Jackie (a social worker) believes that “people want to live happily. People hope they can be happy. … They (the decadent persons) are eager to change. They want to be good. Only that kind of people can change to be good [when conditions are adequate]”. Esther (a beneficiary) personally experienced the power of change and recalled that, “because of the present environment, the present emotion, everything has changed”, by this belief she overcame her life challenges and recovered from depression.
Their support of short-term and long-term changes within the “self-system” (Markus and Nurius , 966) intrinsic to the bodhi nature (Trungpa ) approves the discovery of their authentic self in the proper conditions, as well as the actualisation of their constructive “possible selves” (Markus and Nurius , 954); that is, the ideal selves that individuals desire to become; “the successful self, the creative self, the rich self, the thin self, or the loved and admired self” (Markus and Nurius , 954). By referring to the concept of anātman (non-self 無我), a counsellor reinforces clients to revive from transgressions or life problems.
While self-actualisation remains the key principle in Mahāyāna, it also significantly engages humanistic counselling approaches, including the hierarchy of human needs (Maslow ), and person-centred therapy (Rogers ). These two cultural camps highlight the positive nature of human beings, which builds effective communication in counselling.
2.9 Nurture properties
Nurture properties consist of avidyā (ignorance 無明), along with individual attributes made up of the external factors which influence the life of sentient beings.
2.10 Avidyā(ignorance 無明)
Regardless of situation, the immaculate human nature (inner characteristics) is contaminated by vexations and desires (outer conditions), as expressed by the metaphor “this body is impure, replete with defilements”xi (Watson , 83). The toughest defilement to address is avidyā, which consists of delusion and a false perception of one’s ever-changing environment, which instigates negative emotions, and cognition and behavioural problems. When sentient beings stubbornly holdxii on to avidyā, which is the root of suffering, their mind is blemished, and distorts reality. Dr Chan (a helping service practitioner) analysed distress in the following manner:
“People are pure in nature. There are no defilements; if to otherwise, they are self-created. … From the dimension of the buddha nature, everyone is in brightness; everyone has meaning and value”.
Referring to the goals and strategies of counselling, a counsellor facilitates clients to remove defilements and attain tranquillityxiii, metaphorically brushing away dirt (that is, obstinate vexations) on a mirror (the pure human nature); for which Buddhist elements provide sources related to theories and practices (Zheng ).
2.11 Individual attributes
Although the human nature is consistently pure, sentient beings have individual features, varying according to experience, understandingxiv, and capacity regarding the perception of this “evil world of the five impurities”xv (五濁惡世) (Watson , 114); namely, sahā-lokadhātu (world of saha 娑婆世界). In such a chaotic world, they remain obduratexvi in their delusion, unable to see the ultimate reality, and live with a jumping mindxvii. In order to rectify their misperceptions, a counsellor is competent to apply various techniques in order to deal with individual difficulties and features, which technique is known as upāya (skilful means 方便) in Buddhism (Zheng ).
The fundamental Buddhist worldview comprises pratītya-samutpāda (the law of dependent origination 緣起法), from which arises the doctrines of karma (action 業) and hetu-phala (cause-and-effect 因果).
2.13 Pratītya-samutpāda(the law of dependent origination 緣起法)
Pratītya-samutpāda, the core Buddhist theory across all Buddhist denominations and sects, explicates the formation of all beings in the empirical world. In Buddhism, what is apparent is merely the phenomenal manifestation that results from the aggregate of hetu (causes 因) and saha-kāri-pratyaya (contributing causes 助緣). For instance, a bicycle consists of wheels, tyres, a saddle, brake levers, chains, pedals, and other parts. All of these components appropriately come together and make the bicycle work. If there is a missing part, the bicycle will become inoperative; or if the tyres are on the saddle, instead of on the wheels, the bicycle likewise does not work. This illustrates that nothing is independent but all things are interconnected (Epstein ), which construes the “impermanence, dependence, and insubstantiality of all things” (Wright , 23), and surrenders absolutism (Corless ), which is compatible with the postmodernist view (Watson ). In short, “to exist means to be interdependent” (Abiko , 8). Venerable Chi Yiu further elaborated on it from the dimensions of daily life:
“All things are created by causes and conditions; that is, the connection of causes and conditions. … The connection of causes and conditions represents the occurrence of everything. The meeting of you and me implies the connection of causes and conditions. Our making of friends, many other things, even family, family members are also incurred through the connection of causes and conditions”.
However, the hetu (causes 因) will change, and so will the saha-kāri-pratyaya (contributing causes 助緣); therefore, the phenomenon continues to change with “no lasting form” (Humphreys , 20) only conjuring up a display of substancexviii, showing reality to be fluid, uncertain, and dynamic (Gethin ). This illuminates the transient nature of existence as representing “impermanent phenomena as permanent” (Zopa , 129). This is similar to Jackie’s (a social worker) experience:
“It is cause-and-condition, I agree very much. … I feel that every step relates to causes and conditions. Where there are no causes and conditions. … There will have no changes”.
Existence undergoes stages of change pertaining to “formation, existence, destruction, and void” (Hsu , 2), denoting that “arising, staying, changing, and vanishing” (Hsu , 2) present the phenomenal development of all beings. As Che Wai (a beneficiary) related the cycle of “causes arising when causes exist, causes gathering when causes exist, causes disappearing when causes are lost” that she personally experienced.
This teaching in the Vimalakīrti Nirdeśa Sūtra is defined as “non-abiding”xix – the truth behind all existence in the empirical world. This “non-abiding” nature specifies that “the various phenomena ultimately have no existence – this is the meaning of emptiness”xx (McRae , 43), and is termed “śūnyata” (voidness 空性) in Buddhism. The word “śūnya” in Sanskrit literally means “the swollen” (Conze , 130), referring to hollowness, and representing an insubstantial nature (Zheng ); or with “pregnant” (Jones , 13), referring to potentiality and creativity. When the nature of existence is insubstantial, so is its manifestationxxi; hence, phenomena are delusive, specious, and formlessxxii, and concepts are phantomxxiii. Conclusively, all beings are unreal and dreamlike, from the Buddhist perspective; and so is trespass.
The nature of trespass and transgression is volatile and uncertainxxiv, and these are both induced by a series of causes. In other words, if one of these causes is removed, then the trespass or transgression will not occur. For example, a criminal commits a crime not because of her/his sin nature, as depicted by the notion of bodhi nature, but because of many other reasons, such as poverty, and family problems. This does not imply that the crime committed should be accepted, but that one should accept the influencing power of external factors – as expounded upon earlier by the metaphorical dust on a mirror. This also reveals that a counsellor must empathically investigates the latent causes of a criminal, and facilitate her/him in eliminating unfavourable causes while creating favourable agents.
Owing to “śūnyata” (voidness 空性), the quintessence of prajñā (wisdom 般若) (Shi ), the ultimate truth (Gethin ), all beings are ephemeralxxv and amorphousxxvi; therefore Amara (a beneficiary) sighed, “nothing has never changed. Many things are out of our control”. Agreeing with this, KJ* (a psychiatrist) intelligently perceived the uncertainties of suffering (Shi ), expressing that:
“In fact, good and bad are void. [When] we understand that a good environment is impermanent, [we] will live carefully. But actually, predicaments are also impermanent”.
Change itself is open (Welwood ), unrestricted and unlimited (Rawlinson ), and offers chances for development and growth (Bernhard ), which is a fact worthy of appreciation (Cason and Thompson ). Jackie (a social worker) proclaimed the positive facet of evanescence, relating that “many things will change; and yet, changes create opportunities and changes bring hopes”. This reminds a counsellor to help clients create favourable conditions for change. More importantly, chances pave the way for a process of realising the meaning behind a distressful life, just as LP* (a counsellor) encouraged her clients:
“[It] is a process of self-transformation. … [mis]-perceive that pain is real. But pain is not real. … You [have to] transcend appearance and material form, and even outward form; that is transformation, and full freedom”.
Vimalakīrti in the Sūtra was metaphorically sick, through which he explains temporariness by using his fleeting and deteriorating bodyxxvii that houses an assembly of elements to transitorily form the appearance of a bodyxxviii. He perceives his body “as a conjurer looks on the beings he conjures up … the moon in the water, or a face or form seen in a mirror; as shimmers of heat in a torrid season, as the echo that follows a cry, as clouds in the sky, as foam on the water, bubbles on the water, as a thing no firmer that the trunk of the plantain, no longer lasting that a flash of lightning; …”xxix (McRae , 83). This exhibits a transiently phantom bodyxxx, as with other beings, without a fixed statexxxi, nor a real existence of life or deathxxxii.
The vicissitude of the body is also realised through “the impermanence of the five desires”xxxiii (Watson , 37), referring to the physical sensations of hearing, seeing, smelling, tasting, and touching. The desires for sensory satisfaction are infinite, changing, and contextual. One may like to listen to classical music today but to popular songs tomorrow; or may relish sweet flavours today but sour tomorrow; or may covet a car today but a house tomorrow; and so forth. This represents changes of mind, like a monkey’s mind jumping ideas from idea to idea over time.
The physical and mental representations of sentient beings endorse the principle of anātman (non-self 無我), that is, the existence of selflessxxxiv and egolessxxxv beings. In Buddhism, anātman spells out the changes within individuals related to their physiological bodies and mental states (Watson ), rather than denying the existence of individuals. As explained earlier, sentient beings are non-autonomous because of pratītya-samutpāda (the law of dependent origination 緣起法), bound by conditions and external factors. The absence of autonomy uncovers the limitations of sentient beings, implying that there are no distinctions among individuals in nature. Therefore, there is no difference between “I” and “others”xxxvi, which breaks the dualism within interpersonal relationshipsxxxvii through an “open, unrestricted, immeasurable” (Rawlinson , 141–142) mind. This realises the notion of anātman, which aims to dissolve “self-absorption and egoistic impulses” (Podvoll and Fortuna , 88), surrender self-centredness (Epstein ), banish attachment to self (Parry and Jones ), overcome narcissism (Abe ), and develop an “immediate, non-self-centred response to life as it is” (Magid , 79). As Dr Chan (a helping service practitioner) explained:
“The so-called non-self is not to live in our own world, not to live in a selfish space, … not to work with others through self views, self angles, a narrow self, a selfish world”.
Śūnyata (voidness 空性) incorporates the forsaking of self-centredness and suffering that arise due to mis-perceptions of reality. Dr Chan (a helping service practitioner) looked at it through its positive connotation, relating the following:
“Śūnyata is to get rid of our defilements, get rid of our attachment. … eliminate incorrect perception, … terminate our delusive thoughts, and then return to the ultimate reality, to the truth. … dispose of biases, dispose of prejudices, dispose of stubbornness, dispose of attachment, dispose of ideology, dispose of hatred, dispose of extant negative psychological attributes”.
2.14 Karma and cause-and-effect
As different causes come together and form an event, according to pratītya-samutpāda (the law of dependent origination 緣起法), some causes are created and incur a cause-and-effect, to wit, karma (action 業) that is carried forward from previous actions (Thubten ). An example of this is a body which has arisen from karmic effectxxxviii. Although sentient beings are ever-changing without fixed forms, karma does not fade out but affects lifexxxix, which is “resultant of the forces brought into action” (Soothill , 97). Jackie (a social worker), as a Buddhist, believed this principle, relating that:
“Things contain cause-and-effect. Sometimes, [I] experience [cause-and- effect] in [my] work. Regardless of whether [things] are going well or not, there are causes and consequences. In daily life, this can be explained”.
In accordance with cause-and-effect, good karma (action 業) comes from good actions that bring about happiness to oneself and others (Zopa ), and bad karma likewise comes from bad actionsxl. In other words, good actions create good karma and bad actions create bad karma (Craig, Chase, and Lama ). Thus, “this cause makes this fruit. You make what causes and creates what fruit”, as Yim Na (a Buddhist volunteer) assented.
Therefore, karma (action 業), like a “wake-up call” (Thubten , 38), governs Buddhists (Reichenbach ) to behave correctly and take responsibility for their own behaviour (Conze ). When believing in karma, individuals can peacefully accept reality (Kain ). This is the reason that Dun Li (a beneficiary) appreciated Buddhist teachings, as following quoted here:
“In Buddhism, the concept of cause-and-effect is a cane guiding me peacefully and at ease. … Yet experiencing cause-and-effect in [my] daily life makes me understand that luck is created by myself and fate is made by my expectations. [I] firmly believe fate is in my hand”.
Betty (a Buddhist volunteer) echoed:
“I believe the view of cause-and-effect. In Buddhism, regarding this concept, I might have hurt other people in my previous lives. [Therefore, I] calmly face karma, confess, and reflect on whether I have hurt anyone. … [I] am more vigilant with myself. I make good relationships with others every minute”.
JC* (a psychiatrist) summarised karma in that “the theory of cause-and-effect asks responsibilities of self [behaviour]”, which applies fairly to all beings alike, just as Pema Kazhuo (a beneficiary) concurred, explaining that “the operation of cause-and-effect [responds to] an individual’s behaviour. It is really fair”.
The Buddhist worldviews illuminate the latent causes of mental illnesses, as diagnosed here by KJ* (a psychiatrist):
“The law of dependent origination in Buddhism explains that formation is produced by an aggregate of causes and termination is induced by the loss of causes. Our problems are always related to the distortion of cause-and-effect. … Therefore, we suffer. But many people are still warping cause-and-effect, not accepting the consequences. … [If you] understand this cause-and-effect, evaluate it, and change [your] behaviour, thoughts, speech – in fact, the problem will have been solved”.
Buddhist worldviews also heighten the hopes of positive change in unfavourable environments, and simultaneously emphasise self-responsibility, which corresponds to humanistic psychotherapy; for instance, existential psychotherapy (Yalom ), and person-centred therapy (Rogers ).
2.15 Life views
2.15.1 Du ḥ kha(suffering 苦)
Du ḥkha centres on the life views of Buddhism connected to powerlessness and dissatisfaction with such a transient life (Ray  and Harvey ). Life is so imperfect (Huang ) and uncontainable (Schneider and Tong ), causing individuals to suffer from distressxli where afflictions are inevitable and inescapable (Flowers and Stahl ) due to attachment (Boeree & George ) and accumulated “destructive karma” (Thubten , 38) in previous livesxlii. Rinpoche K* (a Buddhist monk) elaborated on this as follows:
“Our present life, regardless of bodily, physiological, or psychological suffering, is in fact, rooted in bad karma from previous lives”.
Polly (a clinical psychologist) understood that suffering is induced by infinite desire:
“The meaning of suffering in Buddhism is very deep. Greed coming from desire is an affliction. Because you are greedy, you will expose yourself to hope for something. The results of such a hope contain two aspects: achieved, or not achieved. Therefore, your mind ever worries about gains and losses”.
Thus, suffering is self-created, to which Amara (a beneficiary) agreed:
“These afflictions are made by ourselves. In fact, they are our karma. I feel our suffering is non-stop”.
However, according to pratītya-samutpāda (the law of dependent origination 緣起法), suffering is also unreal and speciousxliii, and will become void and fade out. So is self, which is constantly changing, both physically and mentally (Townsend and Kaklauskas ). The unreal self and delusive suffering are present and continuously changing in response to surrounding conditions and karma (action 業). With a non-permanent self entity (Bernhard ), individuals experience the fact that “life is a process” (Bernhard , 40), through which one learns to open one’s heart to accept life’s difficulties (Bernhard ) and also oneself (Flowers and Stahl ).
There is a consensus across Eastern and Western philosophers regarding the nature of suffering, in that no distinction is made as to whether it is good or bad. There are a few exceptions to this rule: for example, Schopenhauer always viewed suffering pessimistically (App  and Wicks ). However, Buddhism expounds on du ḥ kha (suffering 苦) through a realistic view of life and the phenomenal world, neither optimistic nor pessimistic (Rahula ), and offers ways of expunging du ḥ kha, from which Buddhists search for meaning in life through suffering, which is concordant with person-centred therapy (Rogers ). In particular, the mission of Mahāyāna Buddhists is to transcend suffering (Mizuno ) through an “impermanent, uncertain, unpredictable, ever-changing” (Bernhard , 28) life by practising bodhicitta (Ponlop ), which will be elaborated upon in the coming section.
2.15.2 The other shore(彼岸)
Death in Buddhism lies within the spectrum of life, instead of representing the end of life. Buddhists aim at ceasing their involvement in sa ṃ sāra (the cycle of birth and death 輪迴) and attaining nirvā ṇ a (perfect stillness 涅槃), or “the other shore”, where is all is peaceful, luminous, and hopeful, and where sentient beings are extricated from rebirth (Abe ). Amara (a beneficiary) elucidated her fearlessness towards death, aided by her drawing (Figure 2); while at the same time she admitted that “the other shore” will be accessible only by enduring Buddhist practices.
“That ‘shore’ is full of hopes. Death unnecessarily stands for gloominess. Perhaps, after you die, you can reach ‘that shore’”.
Amara (a beneficiary) continued to explain her ideas, reiterating that the gap between “this shore” and “the other shore” was extremely wide, leading her to row upstream very hard. Nevertheless, she was confident in reaching it if she incessantly practised vipaśyanā (insight meditation 內觀). The transcendent individuals in the upper part of her drawing show her firm confidence in the possibility of finally attaining “the other shore”.
2.16 The bodhisattva spirit
The bodhisattva spirit signals a landmark in Mahāyāna that designates a bodhisattva’s missionary career, bearing the welfare of sentient beings through catvāri apramānāni (the four immeasurables 四無量心) activated by the intrinsic bodhicitta. In Sanskrit, “bodhi”, which stems from “budh” (Dayal [1932/1999], 18), refers to enlightenment (Leighton ); while “sattva”, is derived from “sant”, and denotes sentient beings (Leighton ). A bodhisattva, a “buddha-to-be” (Harrison , 67 and Nagao , 73), has become enlightened and is able to enter nirvā ṇ a (perfect stillness 涅槃), but is willing to live in the loka (the secular world 世間) in order to give succour to suffering living beings (Krishan  and Wray et al. ). As a “heroic benefactor” (Leighton , 1), a bodhisattva remains attentive to “the profound altruistic concern that all living beings become enlightened” (Sasaki , 11), and “is dedicated to saving sentient beings from affliction,” as affirmed by Joe (a counsellor). For this, a bodhisattva unreservedly “gives all [s/he] possesses as a gift to others”xliv (Watson , 59), emphasising both the “act of living” (Kawamura , 106) and their contribution to society, which is imitated admirably by Chinese Mahayanists (Suzuki /[1981b], Lancaster ).
In Mahāyāna, a bodhisattva, in a broad sense, could be anyone, and is not restricted to celestial bodhisattvas (Harrison ), regarding which Betty (a Buddhist volunteer) understood that “whoever can help other people is a bodhisattva; and everybody can do it”. In addition to the idea that a bodhisattva is also a “spiritual helper” (Leighton , x) facilitating sentient beings to achieve personal growth and a meaningful life, helping professionals (such as counsellors, clinical psychologists, nurses, and social workers) perform bodhisattva tasks, providing human services to assist people in ameliorating their quality of life (Morales, Sheafor, and Scot ). Dr Li (a psychiatrist) then utilised a metaphor that illustrates how a psychiatrist works as a bodhisattva, explaining:
“A doctor (psychiatrist) is to enable patients to relieve suffering and acquire happiness. In the bodhisattva path, rescuing others is necessary. Therefore, a doctor needs to save people, to make patients free from affliction and have happiness”.
A bodhisattva practises bodhisattva-mārga (the bodhisattva path菩薩道) through her/his altruistic activities (Batchelor ), from which s/he also gains benefits (Zopa ), particularly personal development (Hsing-Yun ). In order to enlighten other people, a bodhisattva enlightens her/himself first, demonstrating that this mutually beneficial relationship forms self-benefiting altruism, with the core of the bodhisattva spirit (Li ) shrinking away from self-centred altruism towards selflessly “perfect altruism” (Williams , 29). Self-benefiting altruism (that is, the bodhisattva spirit) inspires the propositions for counselling from within this counselling framework, especially in the practice of catvāri apramānāni (the four immeasurables 四無量心).
A bodhisattva cares about everybody and will not give up anyonexlv, and bearing the suffering of sentient beingsxlvi, which presents mahāmaitrī-mahākarunā (great loving-kindness and great compassion 大慈大悲) – the elements of catvāri apramānāni (the four immeasurables 四無量心) – activated by bodhicitta (菩提心).
2.16.1 Bodhicitta(enlightened mind 菩提心)
Bodhicitta is made up of “bodhi” and “citta”, in which the former means “awakening”, as explained earlier, and “citta”, which pertains directly to the mind (Dayal [1932/1999]). Also known by the full term “anuttarā-samyak-sa ṃ bodhi”xlvii (Watson , 31) (the highest wisdom of awakening 無上正等正覺), this enlightened mind (Bloom , Gethin ) is concerned with “minds on the Great Vehicle”xlviii (Watson , 44), initiating the bodhisattva’s vow on behalf of all beings (Lan ). On one hand, “activating bodhicitta is to make a vow regarding the benefit of sentient beings”, Joe asserted. On another hand, HW* (a helping service practitioner) perceived that “activating bodhicitta is the process of practising Buddhist teachings”. In being a bodhisattva, bodhicitta is the fundamental quality that activates catvāri apramānāni (the four immeasurables 四無量心), especially karu ṇ ā (compassion 悲), which was addressed by Polly (a clinical psychiatrist) when she elucidated that “activating this vow is caused by compassionate regrets for the suffering of all beings”.
2.16.2 Catvāri apramānāni(the four immeasurables 四無量心)
Based on śūnyata (voidness 空性) (Nakamura /), catvāri apramānāni, which comprises maitr ī (loving-kindness 慈), karu ṇ ā (compassion 悲), mudit ā (empathetic joy 喜), and upek ṣa (equanimity 捨), negates the discrimination between “myself” and “others”, which guides not only the mental capabilities of a bodhisattva, but also the behavioural performance, for the mission of serving sentient beings (Chen ).
Maitr ī (loving-kindness 慈), from a Sanskrit root meaning “friendliness” (Nakamura /), yearns for sentient beings to experience cheerfulness (Wallace ), and aims to deliver “contentment to all beings”xlix (Watson , 84) and to cope with cruelty (Salzberg ). Venerable Thong Hong put it simply, “loving-kindness is to give happiness to people”, or as VHU* (a Buddhist nun) similarly denoted, “loving-kindness is to enable living beings to be happy”.
While maitr ī (loving-kindness 慈) leans towards happiness, karu ṇ ā (compassion 悲) implies afflictions, representing a bodhisattva’s defining passion (Gomez ) and a critical motivation for altruistic contribution (Harvey ). Venerable Foo Chai preached that, “compassion is to liberate one from his suffering”, and “[save] living beings”l (Watson , 60). Since the buddha nature represents the inborn human nature, everyone carries an innate sense of compassion that can be applied to counselling as ML* (a counsellor) experienced:
“I will encourage them (clients) to empathically observe others around them. Compassionate observation is also a process of self learning”.
Muditā (empathetic joy 喜) illustrates that one does not simply feel satisfied with “one’s own pleasure yet celebrate[s] the pleasure of others”li (McRae , 161), which addresses the issue of jealousy (Harvey , Wallace ) and causes the practitioner to become humble. LP* (a counsellor) defined “empathetic joy as …to rejoice in other people’s success, be happy because they are happy”. In “developing joy with others’ success and well-being”, one is “happy for others’ achievements without [feeling] jealousy”, Venerable Sander and Venerable Yu Chun supplemented respectively.
Upek ṣ a (equanimity 捨) consists of three aspects: generosity, egalitarianism, and indiscrimination. First, as Venerable Chi Yiu preached, from the domain of “forsakes one’s various possessions”lii (McRae , 162), “upek ṣ a is to share with sentient beings what you have and what you should enjoy”. Second, the “principle of equanimity”liii (Watson 1997, 40) “means egalitarianism” (Venerable Thong Hong), promoting the principle that there are no differences among any sentient beings. A bodhisattva cares for every individual, regardless of good or bad. Thus, upek ṣ a develops to the third dimension, indiscriminationliv. Esther insightfully related her understanding that “sentient beings are equal. This reminds us not to develop a discriminative mind. … In fact, this can apply to life”. Applying upek ṣ a to counselling, LP (a counsellor) shared that “equanimity implies that there are no differences between clients and myself”.
The achievement of upek ṣ a (equanimity 捨) enables one to possess tranquillity, a balanced mind (Harvey ), and an ordinary mind (Magid ) to observe reality as it is (Pruett ), and to empathically look after other people’s distress with no sentimentalised reactions (Manne-Lewis ).
The unity of the four interdependent and inseparable essentials of catvāri apramānāni (the four immeasurables 四無量心), represents their individual functions and interactions, working together just as do hands, feet, body trunk, and organs. Maitr ī (loving-kindness 慈) and karu ṇ ā (compassion 悲) are two sides of a coin (Wallace ), as “intertwined forces” (Salzberg , x), while mudit ā (empathetic joy 喜) strengthens maitr ī, and vice versa. Only when upek ṣ a (equanimity 捨) is activated, can the other three components also activate to produce “boundless benevolence” (Oi , 9) and limitless compassion, leading to great wisdom (Tada , Wray ), which perfects catvāri apramānāni (Wallace ). A reminder from VHY* (a Buddhist nun) that “you have to indiscriminately treat others with loving-kindness and compassion”, illustrates the interactive relationship among them. The four essentials relate to diverse aspects and feelings, but aim towards the same path, that is, nirvā ṇ a (perfect stillness 涅槃), the spiritual state of tranquillity. Catvāri apramānāni has often been used for psychological and spiritual growth (Kornfield, Dass, and Miyuki ), on which these theories applied to counselling settings will be elaborated in the next part.
2.17 Propositions for counselling
Buddhist teachings, as discussed previously, offer a far-reaching opportunity for healing through insightful self-awareness (Thurman ), which supports the counselling theories from within this counselling framework, covering four tiers: first, its therapeutic mission and goals; second, the roles and qualities of a counsellor; third, case conceptualisation, therapeutic relationships, and therapeutic strategies; and lastly, therapeutic tactics, skills, and techniques.
2.18 Therapeutic mission
A bodhisattva practises her/his sacred mission by implementing bodhicitta in order “to benefit sentient beings”lv (McRae , 82), relieve them from sufferinglvi (Keown ), and prune away avidyā (ignorance 無明) (Claxton ) and misconceptions. Freedom from sufferinglvii indicates significant personal growth, marking the presence of two aspects: self attainment, and altruismlviii. A bodhisattva aims to help sentient beings in order to release them from desire and cause them to acquire an inherently pure mindlix so that they can bring themselves happinesslx. Also, s/he strives to lead sentient beings to be bodhisattvas and help otherslxi. In practising the “helper therapy principle” (Riessman , 28), a bodhisattva enables sufferers to help others who are suffering from similar distress. In conclusion, a bodhisattva is a bodhisattva to her/himself as well as to other people for the purpose of attaining a richly nuanced level of well-being, as defined by Fromm (, 63):
“Well-being is the state of having arrived at the full development of reason not in the sense of a merely intellectual judgement, but in that of grasping truth by ‘letting things to be’ (to use Heidegger’s term) as they are. Well-being is possible only to the degree to which one has overcome one’s narcissism; to the degree to which one’s open, responsive, sensitive, awake, empty (in the Zen sense). Well-being means to be fully related to man and nature affectively, to overcome separateness and alienation, to arrive at the experience of oneness with all that exists – and yet to experience myself at the same time as the separate entity I am, as the in-dividual. Well-being means to be fully born, to become what one potentially is; it means to have the full capacity for joy and for sadness or, to put it still differently, to awake from the half-slumber the average man lives in, and to be fully awake. If it is all that, it means also to be creative; that is, to react and to respond to myself, to others, to everything that exists-to react and to respond as the real, total man I am to the reality of everybody and everything as he or it is. In this act of true response lies the area of creativity, of seeing the world as it is and experiencing it as my world, the world created and transformed by my creative grasp of it, so that the world ceases to be a strange world ‘over there’ and becomes my world. Well-being means, finally, to drop one’s ego, to give up greed, to cease chasing after the preservation and the aggrandisement of the ego, to be and to experience oneself in the act of being, not in having, preserving, coveting, using”.
Fromm’s () delineation of well-being affirms that the inborn wisdom and enlightenment of sentient beings offer the qualities of self-actualisation that benefit not only oneself, but also others and society. Similarly, a counsellor believes that anyone will tend to change towards the direction of truth, good and beauty; and this can result from any adversity, when the favourable conditions and environment are offered. The mission of a counsellor in a “therapeutic venture” (Corey , 6) is therefore to facilitate clients in alleviating their distress and solving problems by her/himself (acting as her/his own bodhisattva), and to eventually acquiring inner peace due to “the full awakening of the total personality to reality” (Fromm , 67).
2.19 Therapeutic goals
In fulfilling this mission, the therapeutic goals are: first, to rejuvenate the true nature of sentient beings, that is, to aid them in becoming their “absolute self” (Reichenbach , 54) and achieving genuine “human-beingness” (Trungpa , 126); second, to liberate them from avidyā (ignorance 無明) and tri-do ṣ a (three poisons 三毒), or rāga (greed 貪), dve ṣ a (hatred 嗔), and moha (delusion 癡). As a result, they attain “spiritual freedom” (Reichenbach , 54), with no fears, anxiety, or worries. In order to enable clients to achieve enlightenment, a counsellor seeks to guide them away from self-centredness (Krieglstein ). When clients let go of egotism, they can accurately perceive reality, truly get in touch with their authentic self, and sincerely connect with other people. Well-being comes from genuine acceptance of self and others, as suggested by Fromm ().
2.20 Roles of a counsellor
A counsellor, acting like a bodhisattva, plays the roles of therapist and facilitator in order to fulfil the therapeutic mission and goals.
2.20.1 A therapist
A bodhisattva is “the physician king, healing the host of illnesses”lxii (McRae , 110), where “illnesses” refers to afflictions and psychological problems. Dr Chan (a helping service practitioner) expounded on this facet in the following manner:
“The Buddha is a great doctor, … dealing with our ignorance. Buddhism offers a theoretical base which supports counselling theories”.
Metaphorically, to be an “inexhaustible lamp”lxiii refers to the illumination of the darkness, equivalent to the mission of a counsellor who helps clients leave their darkest life period behind, regarding which Dr. Li (a psychiatrist) further explained, “in Buddhism, this is the ‘lamp of heart’, that is, spiritual transmission: being willing to experience through the heart”. His emphasis on heartily caring for patients is reminiscent of a helping service practitioner who practises maitr ī (loving-kindness 慈) and karu ṇ ā (compassion 悲) towards clients. Thus, a compassionate therapist advocates the client-centred principle. “[This] doesn’t focus on [the therapist], but on the patient. … [It] isn’t for the self [of the therapist], but follows the patient’s needs”, VHY* (a Buddhist nun) reiterated.
2.20.2 A facilitator
A bodhisattva is also “the Great Guide of All”lxiv (McRae , 74), who “[releases] people from their delusions”lxv (McRae , 139), acting as a life coachlxvi. “A good bodhisattva and kalyā ṇ amitra (a good companion 善知識) must inspire [her/his] patients to develop faith [in the law of karma], virtuous behaviour (śīla in Sanskrit), generosity, and wisdom, so that [the patients] will be able to find happiness in their present and future lives”, related Venerable Sander.
Summarising the role of a bodhisattva in a counselling setting, Venerable Sander continued, “a counsellor should aim to not only relieve the patient’s distress, but also to teach him to take care of himself using dharma, and to develop an aim in life to find happiness in the present life in a wise way, as well as in the future life, and even the happiness of nirvā ṇ a”, that is, blissful well-being (Conze ).
2.21 Qualities of a counsellor
Consummating her/his mission, goals, and roles, a counsellor embodies three qualities, which pertain to wisdom, congruence, and self-cherishing; not only for the sake of clients, but also for personal and career development when exposing clients’ adversities.
Wisdom represents a cluster of attributes: in additional to sinceritylxvii, a profound mindlxviii, and bodhicitta, it also covers non-dualism, maitr ī (loving-kindness 慈), karu ṇ ā (compassion 悲), mudit ā (empathetic joy 喜), and upek ṣ a (equanimity 捨). Having attained compassionate wisdom (Slater ) to maintain a balanced mind and engage a mindfully psychological state in respect to emotion, cognition, behaviour, and spirituality (Kristeller and Jones ), a counsellor “must purify [her/] his mind”lxix (Watson , 29) posits “in equality without dualism”lxx (Watson , 106).
A purified mind is a non-self-centred mind which is non-judgemental and impartial, without bias, prejudice, preconception, and unfairness. Emerging out of non-duality and indiscrimination, it enables a counsellor to see reality correctly without distortionlxxi, build mutual trust with clients, and touch clients’ inner feelings more easily. Non-duality refers to the absence of positive or negative criticism, which opens a counsellor’s mind to the greatest level of acceptance without avoidance (Magid ) and allows the counsellor to create possible solutions. Based on indiscrimination and impartiality, or upek ṣ a (equanimity 捨) in Mahāyāna and unconditional regard in person-centred therapy, a counsellor does pass judgement on clients whoever they may be. With a pure mind, having no non-dualism or discrimination, a counsellor is able to practise maitr ī (loving-kindness 慈) and karu ṇ ā (compassion 悲), “the true spirit of Buddhism” (Dockett and North-Schulte , 231), for this “compassionate service” (Silverberg , 239), especially in the “talking cure” (Glaser , 5) related modes of caring professions. KJ* (a psychiatrist) illuminated the prominence of this spirit:
“[A counsellor] must be compassionate, and have loving-kindness and compassion. [When a counsellor] has the heart of loving-kindness and compassion, [clients] will trust you (the counsellor)”.
As “a compassionate witness” (Kornfield , 220) who heartily cares for clients, a counsellor better understands clients (Whipps ) when s/he “experience[s] what patients experience. … Most importantly, [a counsellor] can experience [these things] through the heart”, Dr. Li (a psychiatrist) continued to share his empathic understanding:
“I do my best to look after patients, to get involve in their daily life, to enter their life. I consider whether I understand them, because, [I] must understand them in order to help them. Otherwise, [I] cannot help them”.
Empathic understanding results from “nowness” (Brandon , 143) and non-judgement, and reflects “empathetic resonance” (Prendergast [2003b], 102) in responding to a client’s internal feelings and thoughts, as though the counsellor had experienced it intimately and directly (Hunt ), showing thought empathy (Burns ) and feeling empathy (Burns ).
In order to empathically understand clients, karu ṇ ā (compassion 悲) is a key attribute, as elaborated here by Polly (a clinical psychologist):
“When [we] can do such basic work (compassion), [we] have helped him (a client) to recognize his emotion. When a person can recognise his own emotion, and can listen to his [inner] voice, he has a natural ability … [When] a person can see her/himself in other people – in fact, I (a clinical psychologist) function as a mirror, and can more or less help [him] to see himself”.
Through empathy, a compassionate counsellor can also rejoice in a clients’ happiness and achievements, which is known as mudit ā (empathetic joy 喜). The capability of feeling the happiness and sadness of clients as they are differentiates a bodhisattva-counsellor from a counselling technician.
Congruence refers to the ability to “be myself” (Bondarenko , 10) and be transparent to oneself (Cornelius-White ), which leads a counsellor to develop openness, unconditional regards and empathic understanding towards clients (Quinn  and Rogers ). In order to be genuine, a counsellor must be able to listen to clients non-judgementally (Rogers and Nelson ) and to facilitate clients in unveiling their genuineness, thereby allowing clients to enhance their self-awareness and express their true feelings (Rogers , Quinn  and Cornelius-White ).
A counsellor, also an ordinary person, has life challenges (Morales, Sheafor, and Scot ) that can become assets in her/his counselling career, because a “wounded healer” (Stone , 48) may provide greater healing effects to clients (Kornfield ) if the counsellor is congruent to her/his true self, experience, and feelings. S/he is in this way able to feel the distress empathically. As Dr. Li (a psychiatrist) reiterated:
“The Buddha perceives his own suffering first, and also perceives suffering in the secular world, in which he’s also a member. Therefore, he needs to free [himself] from his afflictions, and then rescue suffering people”.
Compassion fatigue, similar to the “sentimental compassion”lxxii (McRae , 112) denoted in the Sūtra, severely deteriorates the enthusiasm of counsellors, resulting in physical and emotional exhaustion due to prolonged exposure to caring for others’ tribulations through codependency (Walley ). Self-cherishing is a panacea for enabling a counsellor to take care of her/himself for both personal growth and career development (Bankart ), since, ML* (a counsellor) emphasised as follows:
“[You] have capability and endless energy towards others. You must first know to take care of yourself. … When you reasonably look after yourself, you then have the ability [to taking care of yourself]”.
In order not to “be limited by any affectionate view” (McRae , 112), a counsellor implements prajñālxxiii (wisdom 般若) and upāyalxxiv (skilful means 方便) in order to compassionately and skilfully help clients, while not overwhelming clients with their distress and painlxxv. Initially, a counsellor properly understands the nature of beings, that is, pratītya-samutpāda (the law of dependent origination 緣起法) and śūnyata (voidness 空性), indicating the temporality of existence and that their existence varies in light of karma (action 業) and hetu-phala (cause-and-effect 因果). The effectiveness of a case depends on conditions and causes that are not in the counsellor’s control, reflecting a bilateral counsellor-client relationship.
Also, a counsellor learns self-kindness and self-compassion (Germer  and Ding ), through which s/he retains a positive attitude towards her/himself with the least amount of self-criticism and self-blame (Neff , Neff, Kirkpatrick, and Rude ). This healthy and balanced psychological state enables the counsellor to maintain self-awareness, self-esteem, self-worth, self-acceptance, and self-motivation (Neff , Williams, Stark, and Foster , Neff, Kirkpatrick, and Rude , Neff and Vonk ), which is especially important for counselling practitioners to prevent burnout or compassion fatigue (Patsiopoulos and Buchanan ), and avoid over-involvement in others’ miseries (Cheng ). In order words, a counsellor retains passion to help clientslxxvi but neither attaches themselves to their situation nor over-invests compassionlxxvii, because the bodhi nature is inherent in sentient beings, and is able to adjust her/his mental contentment accordingly.
Self-cherishing, as a learning process, offers chances for a counsellor to have a better self-understanding, and a better overview of life, and to improve her/his professional techniques. During counselling, a counsellor helps clients, and gains insight from them, which is the essence of self-benefiting altruism, resulting from this interactive process.
2.25 Therapeutic relationships: bodhisattva-bodhisattva interplay
As the foundation for the quality of a counsellor, catvāri apramānāni (the four immeasurables 四無量心) also nurtures the therapist-client relationship. HW* (a helping service practitioner) advocated that “catvāri apramānāni is a channel through which to develop the relationship between a counsellor and a client”, while KJ* (a psychiatrist) emphasised the need to “treat other people with loving-kindness, compassion, empathetic joy, and equanimity. Let them (clients) feel loved and accompanied. Don’t let [them] feel alone”.
Through retaining upekṣ a (equanimity 捨), and majoring in samatā (equality平等), both counsellors and clients are equal in nature, in sa ṃ sāra (the cycle of birth and death 輪迴), in karma, and in hetu-phala (cause-and-effect 因果). Superior and inferior are not necessarily distinguishable. This causes Polly (a clinical psychologist) to be humble towards clients, in that “[it] is not really that there is an expert; or rather, that an expert is not superior. An expert is only more experienced, or more willing to learn from sickness. The real expert is that sickness [itself]”. Polly (a clinical psychologist) had experienced this dynamic between counsellor and client, from which she gained mutual benefit that aided her personal growth and career development; that is, self-benefiting altruism.
Counsellors and clients engender an interrelated, “fluid and permeable” (Prendergast [2003a], p. 8), and equal relationship (Raskin ). A counsellor, just like a bodhisattva, helps a client to become a bodhisattva who can help her/himself. In this process, the counsellor may review her/his own problems and better understand her/himself, through which the client becomes a bodhisattva to the counsellor. This interaction within the counselling process provides healing for the client, and self-learning for the counsellor, through which the counsellor experiences “a journey of evolving self–other understanding and growth” (Finlay , 7). This forms a bodhisattva-bodhisattva relationship, through which both parties are counter-partner bodhisattvas, both gaining personal development and potentially furthering self-actualisation. This non-linear interplay, for the counsellor, realises self-benefiting altruism.
2.26 Case conceptualisation
Case conceptualisation contains a series of assessments utilised to investigate the problem(s) of a client, including family and education background, presenting problem(s), and psycho-social development history (Corey ). Hereafter in this study, this term refers to the primordial cause(s) of a client’s suffering.
Sickness in the Sūtra metaphorically refers to “bondage”lxxviii (McRae , 112), “defilement”lxxix (Watson , 70), and “vexation”lxxx (McRae , 83); in other words, suffering. “Ignorance and feelings of attachment”lxxxi (Watson , 65) are the roots of defilement (Chang ). Sentient beings are ignorant of pratītya-samutpāda (the law of dependent origination 緣起法), the ultimate truth of reality, not knowing that existence is a phenomenon formed by causes and conditions. This ignorance leads them to hold on to possessions; for instance, clinging to her/his own bodylxxxii (Watson , 86). This possession of her/his own body directs her/him to eagerly seek after an unchanging substantive body. For instance, individuals often endeavour to maintain good health, good figures, and beautiful faces, and feel dissatisfied with the inevitability of getting old age. In this sense, the body is an aggregate of defilements and sufferinglxxxiii.
The “attachment of self”lxxxiv (McRae , 110), reflected by this clinging on to the body, directs a person to their “centre of gravity” (Roshi , 71), which reinforces a misunderstanding of “the integrative force, the function, that unifies you as yourself” (Roshi , 71). This attachment to self makes one cultivate “desire and greed”lxxxv (Watson , 86) so as to fulfil one’s endless wants. Rāga (greed 貪) leads an individual to seize upon external desires, to wit “troublesome entanglements”lxxxvi (ālambana 攀緣) (Watson , 69), in Buddhism, which causes one to tenaciously hold on to external factors. For instance, an individual will often feel happy when praised, but sad when criticised. This entanglement creates “a confused [view]”lxxxvii (viparyāsa 顛倒) (McRae , 111) that distracts a person from being able to perceive the phenomenal reality and one’s own self. These deluded thoughts magnify “false and empty distinctions”lxxxviii (abhūta-parikalpa 虛妄分別) (Watson , 86) that discriminate between “you” and “I” and reinforce the attachment to “I”, “me”, and “mine” (Flowers and Stahl , 24), building a wall of rejection towards other people and hanging on to self-centredness.
The Sūtra points out that there is a cluster of causes behind suffering, including avidyā (ignorance 無明), ātma-grāha (self-attachment 我執), deluded thoughts, viparyāsa (confused view 顛倒), and abhūta-parikalpa (false dichotomy 虛妄分別), which agitate the bodhi nature of sentient beings and forms a second nature. A counsellor helps clients clarify the most crucial root factor for them from among these causes of suffering and thus helps them improve their second nature.
2.27 Therapeutic strategies
The therapeutic strategies resonate with the views of human nature that have been delved into and targeted early on: first, there is a need for a rejuvenation of purity and awareness; and second, the removal of kleśa (defilement 煩惱), avidyā (ignorance 無明), and moha (delusion 愚癡) is also essential. The former re-discovers the buddha nature, whereas the latter brings about a comfortable life in the empirical world. Indeed, the two strategies are interdependent, emphasising the positive facets of the former and undermining the negative aspects of the latter. As a result, sentient beings can live with “the true self in the here-and-now” (Akizuki , 64), where the present moment not only indicates the exact moment now, but also extends to every moment continuing into the future.
These therapeutic strategies accede to the views of human nature and develop therapeutic tactics that guide the operational purposes in order to fulfil the therapeutic mission and goals, as covered previously.
2.28 Therapeutic tactics
Therapeutic tactics, reflecting therapeutic strategies, embraces three domains: non-dualism, transcendence of kleśa (defilement 煩惱), and gratitude for suffering.
2.28.1 Advaita(non-dualism 不二)
In eliminating kleśa (defilement 煩惱), avidyā (ignorance 無明) and moha (delusion 愚癡), and restoring the bodhi nature, precluding anta-dvaya (duality of extremes 二邊) plays a critical role in awakeninglxxxix (Dalai ). De-polarising two extremes does not deny the existence of the two poles; instead, it accepts the interdependence of two truths: duality in lokasa ṃ v ṛ ti-satya (secular truth 世俗諦), and non-duality in paramārtha (superlative truth 真諦).
In the empirical world, phenomena of opposites do exist; for instance, bright/dark, long/short, white/black; but this relativity does not exist in absolute truth, or paramārtha (superlative truth 真諦), implying that there is “no intrinsic reality” (Dalai ), as explained earlier. If there is no “one” reality and lokasa ṃ v ṛ ti-satya (secular truth 世俗諦) is relatively true, any judgement is therefore contextual and non-absolute. For example, “entering” and “leaving” are relative, meaning that when one enters a forest, that same person is also leaving the forest after s/he has traversed through half of it, even while going in the same direction. So is any judgement of good and bad, or right and wrong. In fact, such pairs of extremes are symbiotic: they are opposite but paired, inter-related, and interdependent (Dao-an ). Where there is no rich, there is no poor; likewise for quick or slow. Judgement relies on comparison: When compared with 5 meters, 10 meters away is far; but compared with 100 meters, 10 meters away is near. In conclusion, advaita (non-dualism 不二) challenges programmed thoughts and the second nature, which enables sentient beings to cross over relativity and personal boundaries so that they can openly accept others and even opposite opinions, and become inclusive.
However, sentient beings mistakenly hold to relativity and suffer from the effects of comparing themselves with others, causing Dr Chan (a helping service practitioner) to illuminate with a sigh:
“We live in relativity. Relativity is opposition. Opposition creates resistance. Resistance yields fighting, and eventually leads to war. People’s vexation originates from relativity. … that is, comparison will cause the loss of autonomy, and become powerlessness”.
Unlike “non-duality therapy” (Fenner , 26) that integrates the empty-mind concept of Zen with the advaita (non-dualism 不二) of Hinduism, the chapter on “Entering the Gate of Non-dualism” in the Sūtra criticises the binary concept and asserts a detachment from dichotomy. Examples include the antitheses between life and deathxc, purity and defilementxci, between good and not goodxcii, and between sin and blessingxciii. These appear to be mutually exclusive: Death cannot come together with life, nor purity with contamination; goodness cannot join with evil, nor trespass with benediction. When getting rid of non-duality, one removes the desire for possession, abases narcissism, and lessens the feeling of being afflictedxciv. However, beings are formed under pratītya-samutpāda (the law of dependent origination 緣起法), and their nature is śūnyata (voidness 空性) without fixed forms or states. Sin is incurred through some certain causes and conditionsxcv, by which a counsellor may understand, from an alternative view, how to help clients lessen their feelings of guilt and reduce their psychological burdens so that clients are more willing to correct their misbehaviour.
2.28.2 Transcendence of defilements
Having understood non-dualism, one can detach her/himself from phenomena that are delusive and contextual. Phenomena as such are insubstantial; therefore, “freedom from attachments” (Inoue , 125) (where attachment is a type of defilement) indicates freedom from clinging to materialistic and psychological desiresxcvi. In Vimalakīrti wisdom, the method is presented where one is instructed to “just eliminate the illness; do not eliminate dharmas”xcvii (McRae , 111), where “illness” means defilements and distress, and “dharma” herein refers to all natural phenomena (Dao-an ). This denotes that one may obviate the causes of suffering but not necessarily discard the phenomenon of suffering itself. While the phenomenon is neutral, the reactions to the phenomenon vary from individual to individual. Similarly, a love film can be romantic to one individual but sorrowful to another, because of disparate life experiences and feelings. More practically, suffering is inevitable in life, but how to deal with suffering is a choice for each individual (Germer ).
When the causes of suffering are eradicated, the phenomenon is only a presence and it is unimportant whether or not it exists because these causes of suffering will no longer evoke negative emotion in the sufferer. In this sense, an individual who is capable of “accepting the world as it is” (Kaklauskas and Olson , 146), disregards whatever afflictions may appear to existxcviii, and attains nirvā ṇ a (perfect stillness 涅槃) through their sufferingxcix; in which nirvā ṇ a refers to the state where afflictions have been expunged. In practice, emotion management itself is the critical issue, rather than negative emotional reactions towards those afflictions that are inseparable from life. In addition to proper emotional management, the individual is able to help other people avoid experiencing agony and help them transcend defilements, which is the achievement of Mahāyāna wisdom.
In one case in this study (Cheng and Tse ), Pureté de Lotus (a beneficiary), who suffered the loss of her spouse, did not intentionally avoid feelings of guilt, although she retained guilty feelings about not staying with her late husband when he was seriously ill. She lived with feelings of guilt, which had no negative impact on her daily life; and she practised good behaviour in order to achieve good karma. Furthermore, she was working as a social worker helping vulnerable people. Her experience is inspiring, in that a counsellor may lead clients to face reality and live with pain, or in other words, to transcend suffering.
2.28.3 Gratitude for suffering
The Sūtra values suffering because sentient beings learn from afflictionc. When they experience suffering, they can understand the nature of existence, and afflictions offer chances for them to discover their potentialityci, to wit personal growth. Treasuring the experience of suffering helps them to realise the meaning of life, like obtaining a pearl after entering an oceancii, implying that suffering is valuable. In this sense, all hindrances that afflict individuals are a learning process through which to overcome their weaknesses and become strongciii.
Beneficiaries in the study were often thankful for the distress that gave them a new life after overcoming their suffering. By way of illustration, Esther re-built her self-confidence and learned forgiveness after recovering from depression, and Che Wai and Chi Sim improved their mother-child relationship, likewise expressing gratitude for their suffering. A counsellor guides clients in managing suffering positively, and in transforming misery into motivation.
2.29 Principles of skills
The Sūtra has inspired two major principles of therapeutic skills, covering upāya (skilful means 方便), and intrigue.
2.29.1 Upāya(skilful means 方便)
Upāya, in aiming to cultivate the well-being of sentient beings (Kaziyama ), is the key principle which a bodhisattva practicesciv (Pye ) flexibly to help sentient beingscv through various methods and techniques, complying with the characteristics of an individual, and that individual’s needs (Schroeder ).
Even though the nature of sentient beings, that is, the buddha nature, is innately identical for all, the karma of individuals is diverse, which manifests differences in presence affected by causes and conditions. Therefore, the background, characters, attributes, habits formed (second nature), and temperament are different from individual to individual. A bodhisattva builds a pure land according to the capabilities and characteristics of these sentient beings, where they are able to attain the pure landcvi, in order to save themcvii, enable them to be peacefulcviii, and eradicate their afflictionscix. Similarly, a counsellor is sensitive to clients’ personality traits when applying counselling models and techniques to each independent therapeutic case, aiming to facilitate them in solving their own problems. HW* (a helping service practitioner) reacted by explicating, “some people prefer self-benefit. … My tactic is to encourage [them] in how to achieve self-benefit. If someone is suited to altruism, I will apply altruism in leading [them] to leave their current predicament”.
Also, a bodhisattva can intelligently make out the individual needs of sentient beings, and fulfil their demandscx. Clients have distinct needs because of their disparate milieu and predicaments; and reacting to their actual needs is particularly vital for reaching “co-constructing solutions” (Corey , 6). Dr. Li (a psychiatrist) shared his experience as follows:
“Upāya is to recognise the individuality of every person, and a bodhisattva fits [each of] them. That is, you need to accommodate patients, but not make patients accommodate you. … If a patient believes in Kuan-Yin (a bodhisattva), then [you] may talk about Kuan-Yin”.
The fictitious sickness (Schroeder ) of Vimalakīrti in the Sūtra highlights “an upayic story” (Schroeder , 75) by exemplifying his feigned body, from which Vimalakīrti preaches the doctrines of anitya (impermanence 無常), non-autonomy, interconnectedness, suffering, and causes of suffering and does not use a fixed method for teaching. When preaching, any method is permissible as long as it achieves the goals, such as when metaphoric fragrance is effectively adopted for facilitationcxi.
With the help of upāya (skilful means 方便), intrigue will then be employed. After a bodhisattva skilfully attracts sentient beings firstcxii by whatever means available, s/he leads them to acquire a meaningful life. In this sense, a counsellor may adroitly draw her/his clients’ attentions, particularly for “complainants” (Corey , 383); that is, involuntary clients who resist counselling services. Converting complainants to “customers” (Corey , 383), clients who are aware of their life difficulties and are willing to seek professional help, is always one of the critical responsibilities of a counsellor.
2.30 Counselling techniques
Counselling, as a “talking cure” (Watson , 6), largely uses verbal activities for healing and facilitation; whereas the Sūtra artfully utilises both verbal and non-verbal expression techniques in order to enhance the readability and effective delivery of prajñā (wisdom 般若) thoughts. Many of the techniques are compatible with those currently used in therapeutic settings, pertaining to metaphor, simile, humour, exaggerating, contrast, confrontation, silence, story-telling, psychoeducation, and role model, illustrating cross-reference between the two disciplines but not excluding other possible techniques for counselling purposes.
A metaphor facilitates an understanding of a concept, the target domain (Kövecses , 4), through another concept, the source conceptual domain (Kövecses , 4). As “humans are metaphorising animals” (Johnson , 159), always performing a metaphorical, imaginative, and “aesthetic function” (Schwabenland , 80), they are able to map a similar frame of reference from the source conceptual domain to the target concept (Schwabenland ).
Metaphorical representations are popularly used not only in Western literature, but also in clinical interpretive practices. For instance, medical anthropologists employ a variety of metaphors in implicitly describing a body, such as the illustration of poison (Kirmayer ). Not only useful in facilitating understanding, metaphors are also utilised in emotional expressions and articulation (Averill , Crawford ), especially for evaluative feelings (Emanatian , Helm ).
Metaphoric preaching is a traditional and powerful approach among teachings in Buddhist scriptures, and one which brings out insightful understandings of the more complex tenets (Cheng  and Sugioka ). In the Sūtra, metaphors are heavily utilised to explain prajñā (wisdom 般若) philosophy. One of these is the illustration of Vimalakīrti’s sickness and his ever-changing body. His sickness connotes anitya (impermanence 無常), and the non-autonomy of all beingscxiii, in which it is presented that the body will get sick, degenerate and diecxiv. Such a body is a phenomenal, delusive, and temporal bodycxv which should be let go of it. Sickness itself functions as a metaphor for a series of bondage – attachmentcxvi and entanglementcxvii that causes suffering.
Similarly, a lotus epitomises such unadulterated and resilient featurescxviii. Growing in grimy mud, an immaculate lotus shows its untainted character, shrinking away from the influence of its contaminated environment, implying its persistence and noble characteristics. Conversely, a lotus will perish in clean earth where it does not get nourishment from marshland, denoting that predicaments and failures are motivations that drive success.
Metaphors serve as a communicative operation in psychotherapy (Witztum, van der Hart, and Friedman ), covering psychoanalytic approaches to investigating clients’ unconsciousness (Punter  and Rogers ), cognitive behavioural therapy (Kopp ), family therapy (Kopp ), solution-focused therapy for problem solving and self reflection (Cheng , Solberg, Nysether, and Steinsbekk , Walsh ), and play therapy (Snow et al. ), particularly using common life experiences as examples (Larkin and Zahourek , Clarke ), and forming a “metaphor therapy” (Kopp , xvi-xvii) to enhance metaphoric communication for emotional ventilation (Laranjeira ).
A simile, a poetic similitude (Bronner ), is usually used in a looser form of association but with a higher degree of common ground of understanding (Punter ); and therefore it offers a more explicit connection between the target concept and the source concept.
The Sūtra uses numerous similes in its preaching, for example, “the inexhaustible lamp”, standing for the bodhisattva’s missionary careercxix; “a conjured person”, indicating the śūnyata (voidness 空性) of living beingscxx; and phantasmic presence, specifying the nature of existencecxxi.
Similes, like metaphors, used in therapeutic settings (Cade ) effectively enable clients to think more deeply as outsiders; in particular, when employed together with confrontation, in order to prevent embarrassment. They are sometimes more effective than metaphors in dealing with children (Callow ).
The use of humour plays an important role in Western religious traditions (Geybels and van Herck ), which is an art from relating funny stories and jokes from religious sources, showing comic and tragic connotations (Taels ) through magnifying and exaggerating effects (Bergson ). The rich humour in Buddhist literature (Van Herck ) purposefully enables one to review her/his life (Taels ).
Fables and parables in the Sūtra are full of “conversational humour” (Dynel , p. 217) that portray the “absurdity of contradiction” (Taels , 26) but exhibit the wisdom of Vimalakīrti (Lamotte 1976/1990). Śāriputra, one of the ten great disciples of the Buddha, displays such irony (Lin 1997b) when failing to argue with a goddess. When he despised the goddess and suggested that she became a god, he was magically changed to the appearance of a goddesscxxii, and thereby understood that there are no gender differences in nature. Humour has been widely adopted in psychotherapy (Banman , Davidson and Brown , Klein , Moran ) as a coping strategy to turn negatives into positives, or pessimism into optimism, and to increase happiness levels (Wilkins and Eisenbraun ).
The technique of exaggeration intensifies the discussion theme in a therapeutic process in order to draw out the creative and imaginative potential of the client (Dolliver , Ciuffardi, Scavelli, and Leonardi ).
In the Sūtra, the chapter “Inconceivable” uses this technique frequently. For example, it elicits thirty-two thousand giant chairs in a one-square-foot cellcxxiii, Sumeru Mountain in a mustard seedcxxiv, and an ocean of water in a tiny haircxxv. These break the relativity of objects, leading one to outpace their habitual thinking mode and open themselves up to limitless feasibility, resulting in not only “the total acceptance of, and opening up to, the transience and fragility of our human condition” (Jones , p. 9), but more crucially, to “the emptying of the wants and desires of the clinging agitated and opinionated ‘I’” (Jones , 9); that is, to full emancipation from self-created afflictions.
Using contrast in Buddhist literature is the traditional method of preaching (Cheng ). In the Sūtra, Vimalakīrti, a layman, rectifies the ten great disciples’ understanding of dharma, spelling out the imperfection of Theravāda (the doctrine of the elders 上座部佛教) and emphasising the Mahāyāna (Great Vehicle 大乘佛教) spirit for the welfare of living beingscxxvi. Also, the reflections of the Fragrance bodhisattvas coming from a peaceful world report the great will of the Buddha and bodhisattvas because they relinquish nirvā ṇ a (perfect stillness 涅槃) and live in such a chaotic sahā-lokadhātu (saha world 娑婆世界) for the sake of sentient beings’ happinesscxxvii. Furthermore, they also share limitless meritcxxviii with all beings. Applying the contrast technique, a counsellor makes comparisons showing the advantages and disadvantages of a client’s decision.
As a therapeutic technique, confrontation bombards clients and pushes them to deeply reflect on their thoughts and feelings (Bakes ) by challenging clients’ “incongruence, discrepancy, inconsistency, or mixed message[s]” (Brems , 256), particularly when they avoid painful feelings (Brink and Farber ); whereas non-hostile “caring confrontation” (Boukydis , 32) or “compassionate confrontation” (Bratter and Sinsheimer , 108) enables clients to enhance their self awareness and clarity regarding their inner world.
The Sūtra repeatedly employs confrontation for the clarification of dharma. Maitreya (彌勒菩薩), the predicted future buddha, was challenged by Vimalakīrti that his ability to become a buddha was no different from that of otherscxxix, which re-states the egalitarianism of beings in nature. Similarly, the goddess confronts Śāriputra’s dogmatism about his removal of flowers from his robe. She then brings up the teaching of indiscriminationcxxx.
Maintaining and breaking silence is a prominent technique in various therapeutic approaches (Lovelady ), especially in person-centred approaches (Brink and Farber ), even for coping with burnout of therapists themselves (Baranowsky ). “Constructive silence” (Egbochuku , 30) and “attentive silence” (International Organization for Migration , 49) allow clients to think deeply, reflect, and express feelings.
The “thunderous silence” (Leighton , 8, McRae , 59) of Vimalakīrti marks his wisdom in that he is capable of surpassing language barriers and transcending the ultimate truth of dharmacxxxi. His silence not only presents the teaching of non-duality by acts, but also offers insight to his audience.
Story-telling engages a long history in religious education (Manternach (), Arthur ) and counselling (McMahon and Watson , Ciuffardi, Scavelli, and Leonardi ), which is able to build rapport, effectively communicate with different levels of audiences (Myers, Tollerud, and Jeon , Larkin and Zahourek ), capture their attention easily, and facilitate self reflection (Ng ). Story-telling also offers clients the opportunity to narrate their experiences and personal ideas (McMahon and Watson ). As a “supernatural agency” (Phillips and Morley , 4), a myth connects personal stories to help clients share ideas and ventilate emotion (Greene ) which can yield healing effects on mental disorders (McClary ). Practitioners use these “creative expressions” (Glazer and Marcum , 131) for grief counselling, including therapy for adolescents.
Stories in the Sūtra produce theatrical effects (Cui ), and are always adapted to drama performance (Golden Lotus Theatre ). The stories of the “inexhaustible lamp”cxxxii illuminate care for sentient beings, and those of “flowers scattered by a goddess”cxxxiii further explain the notion of upek ṣ a (equanimity 捨). They provide an easier means of understanding these profound doctrines.
Psychoeducation combines psychotherapy and education in mental health interventions (Lukens and McFarlane ), especially in cognitive-behavioural approaches (Bauml et al. ), and in family therapy (McFarlane et al. ).
Buddhist canons are collections of preaching, equivalent to psychoeducation in counselling (Cheng ). The Sūtra compiles Vimalakīrti’s preaching, initiated from his sickness that connects the major Mahāyāna theoriescxxxiv, as illustrated previously.
2.30.10 Role model
The systematic “Socratic method” (Howard , 15) has been imitated in therapeutic questioning; thus, Socrates has been much admired as a role model for counsellors. Role modelling is one of the primary techniques in behavioural and cognitive behavioural approaches (Safren et al. , Thigpen et al. ).
The Buddha has demonstrated the “experiential verification” (Szkredka , 193) of the buddha path in the loka (the secular world 世間), role modelling for his followers as depicted in Buddhist literature (Cheng ). A bodhisattva acts as a role model to compassionately save sentient beings, which demonstrates the ideal of Mahayanists (Abe ). In the Sūtra, Vimalakīrti has practised the bodhisattva path and upāya (skilful means 方便), modelling how to implement the bodhisattva spirit and practise upāyacxxxv. For instance, he visits gambling dens, brothels, and wine houses to save them from transgressioncxxxvi, and gains respect from various social classes, including from common peoplecxxxvii.
Reviewing this bodhisattva-spirit-oriented counselling framework, four areas lead to further discussion: interactions between philosophical concepts and propositions for counselling, compatibility between Buddhism and psychotherapy, limitations and future research directions, and the features of this framework.
3.1 Interactions between philosophical concepts and propositions for counselling
A bodhisattva, an awakening sentient being and Mahayanist ideal (Basham ), deeply beholds the original human nature (Abe ) (the buddha nature or bodhi nature), worldviews and life views, which activates bodhicitta (enlightened mind 菩提心) and catvāri apramānāni (the four immeasurables 四無量心). The rise of mahā-maitrī-mahā-karunā (great loving-kindness and great compassion 大慈大悲) reinforces a bodhisattva’s aspiration of enlightening her/himself and other people, which remains close to a counsellor’s mission. This commonality represents the vein of this counselling framework, pertaining to the four layers of propositions for counselling from therapeutic mission to counselling technique, by which a counsellor practises self-benefiting altruism. Each tier functions as the guidance for the next tier: The first tier, covering the therapeutic mission and goals, governs the second tier, which regards the roles and qualities of a counsellor that formulate the therapeutic relationship and strategies, as well as the case conceptualisation. The last tier contains therapeutic tactics, skills, and techniques, which reflects the practicality of the previous tiers.
3.2 Compatibility of Buddhism and psychotherapy
Despite the agreement among the participants that Buddhist teachings are helpful for people affected by emotional disorders and dealing with life adversities, whether or not Buddhist elements can fulfil the requirements of modern counselling or psychotherapy is still refutable among the helping service practitioners in this research. KJ* and Dr. Li (both are psychiatrists and participants of this study) converge on the inborn healing function of Buddhism, in which both Buddhism and psychotherapy are communicative, as KJ* (a psychiatrist) perceived, relating:
“Learning Buddhism is a kind of psychotherapy. … [It] is psychotherapy for the whole life. … Buddhism mainly raises suffering. Suffering is psychopathology. … Largely, it is about psychological aetiology. It (Buddhism) is about expunging distress and achieving happiness. This is identical to the objective of psychotherapy”.
Nevertheless, Dr. Li (a psychiatrist) identified a point of divergence, arguing,
“Buddhism and psychiatry are identical in mission, namely, freedom from suffering and acquisition of happiness. This is the core. However, there are differences in nature to some extent”.
Focusing on their similarities, KJ* (a psychiatrist) traced the interaction between Buddhism and psychoanalysis, as well as later humanistic approaches, reiterating,
“Jung advocated individuation since the 1920s or 1930s. Individuation raises [the idea] that people search for an authentic self. Later, humanistic psychotherapy … elicits actualisation and transcendence. … This may be considered [to be similar to] the concept of pursuing to be a buddha. … [Mahāyāna] refers to how to develop a human being’s buddha nature, self nature and potentiality, and so on. This and client-centred therapy in the West are different in approach but with similar results, talking about the real self in a similar way to Buddhism”.
In contrast, Dr. Li (a psychiatrist) emphasised the religious aspect of Buddhism that is ambivalent towards the objective of psychiatry, commenting:
“Buddhism focuses on the supermundane world, while psychiatrists focus on the secular world. The two are different from each other. One is superlative truth, and one is secular truth. Even though they cooperate compulsorily, it is difficult. … One more core problem that resists us … needs self breakthrough, self transcendence, and have a chance to reach the supermudane world, and reach the bodhisattva path. Traditional psychiatry or counselling, basically is to strengthen the self, but not to transcend the self. We don’t have this plan. Therefore, on this dimension, we attain a better self, but do not attain a transcendent self”.
However, Dr. Li’s (a psychiatrist) opinion overlooked the teaching that a Mahāyāna bodhisattva serves sentient beings in the secular world, for which using catvāri apramānāni (the four immeasurables 四無量心) to accomplish the bodhisattva’s vow targets the implementation of bodhisattva-mārga (the bodhisattva path菩薩道) for rooting out suffering. In this sense, the paramount mission of Buddhism, particularly for Mahāyāna, is to extinguish the afflictions of sentient beings, which is congenial to psychotherapy.
3.3 Limitations and future research directions
The limitations of this research and directions for future research involve three premises: first, this counselling framework does not present much of a therapeutic process due to very few sources from the Sūtra. Grounded on this bodhisattva-spirit-oriented counselling framework, future studies are advisable to develop a counselling process, and a training manual, which can result in formulation of a counselling model. Second, this research, as an exploratory study, disregarded psychotherapy process research to evaluate the association, interaction, and bilateral influence of therapeutic process-outcome effects (Marmar , Beutler  and Garfield ); and thus was unable to fully validate the detailed implementation of this framework. Future projects, therefore, are recommended for carrying out psychotherapy process research designs to tone up this embryonic inquisition. Lastly, the research outcomes are supported by textual and qualitative data, to which further future studies are proposed, to use surveys and quantitative data to validate these results.
3.4 Characteristics of this counselling framework
This bodhisattva-spirit-oriented counselling framework focuses on the inner revolution (Thurman ), a self-help approach as a sword of wisdom expunging hindrancescxxxviii, through “a journey of understanding one’s own experience” (Kaklauskas and Olson , 136) with the aid of “edifying” (Watson , 84) Buddhist wisdom. This self healing characteristic not only provides practicable teachings for Buddhists to tackle their life difficulties, as evidenced by the beneficiaries in this research, but also for non-Buddhists who may seek to help themselves through counselling settings. In this respect, this counselling framework chiefly aims at the long-term effectiveness incurred by thought transformation and self-actualisation, rather than at short-term solutions.
As a proponent of the bodhisattva spirit, this counselling framework not only advocates an “I-thou relation” (Buber [1923/1937], ix) respecting a person as a subject, but most importantly establishes bodhisattva-bodhisattva interplay between counsellor and client, affirming egalitarianism and resulting in self-benefiting altruism through non-judgementalism, acceptance, and empathic understanding (Brown, Elkonin, and Naicker ), which are concordant with Mahāyāna philosophy and humanistic therapies.
Moreover, this research synchronises a doctrinal approach substantiated by qualitative data, from which it voices Buddhist values directly from Buddhist textual evidence. This mixed method differentiates itself from the available models of “Buddhist-inspired psychotherapy” (Watson , 249 and Dow , 273), and accentuates the significance of primary data sources in studying Buddhist-informed therapeutic interventions. This may offer references for scholars who are interested in studying Buddhist-related psychotherapy as supported by first-hand data, and in applying Buddhist teachings to helping or caring professions differently.
This cross-disciplinary research, for a theory-building purpose, re-interprets the Vimalakīrti Nirdeśa Sūtra (維摩詰所說經) as to its applicability on the secular level, and applies its wisdom to propositions for counselling based on its philosophical constructs. It covers the overarching Mahāyāna (Great Vehicle 大乘佛教) doctrines, focusing on prajñā (wisdom 般若), which shapes a counselling framework that may offer fundamental elements for use in specific therapeutic settings or populations, such as family therapy, bereavement, and mental health interventions. This bodhisattva-spirit-oriented counselling framework emphasises mind training and thought transformation, which enables clients to transcend self-created suffering produced by ignorance, dualism, and attachment to self. This self-help approach focuses on a sense of self responsibility, the acquisition of innate resources, including the authentic self, and self-actualisation, through an inclusiveness between counsellor and client. This dynamic strengthens the connected and the one being connected during the counselling process, forming bodhisattva-bodhisattva interplay, where both parties act as the bodhisattva for themselves (self-benefiting) as for their counter-partner (altruism). This interplay achieves self-benefiting altruism through the letting go of self-centredness and through bearing the afflictions of other people. However, this counselling framework is still in development, even though it does present the practicality of bodhisattva-mārga (the bodhisattva path 菩薩道) in the contemporary milieu, substantiated by canonical evidence and the lived experiences of participants in this research.
i“The Buddha said, ‘Ānanda, this sūtra is named the Discourse of Vimalakīrti”. (McRae , 179) 「佛言:阿難!是經名為“維摩詰所說”。」《囑累品第十四》T14, no. 0475, p. 0557b21.
ii“The characteristics of the minds of all sentient beings are likewise, in being without defilement”. (McRae , 93) 「一切眾生心相無垢。」《弟子品第三》T14, no. 0475, p. 0541b14-15.
iii“All sentient beings are the characteristic of bodhi”. (McRae , 98) 「一切眾生即菩提相。」《菩薩品第四》T14, no. 0475, p. 0542a35.
iv“All living beings are a part of Suchness”. (Watson 1997, 53)「一切眾生皆如也。」《菩薩品第四》T14, no. 0475, p. 0542a33.
v“identical with living beings, free of distinctions with regard to things” (Watson 1997, 131) 「同眾生,於諸法無分別。」《見阿閦佛品第十二》T14, no. 0475, p. 0554c36-37.
vi“do not differentiate yourself from the host of Maras and the sensory troubles” (McRae , 89) 「汝與眾魔,及諸塵勞,等無有異。」《弟子品第三》T14, no. 0475, p. 0540b25-26.
vii“If you, Maitreya, are able to attain anuttarā-samyak-sa ṃbodhi, then all living beings should likewise be able to attain it. Why? Because all living beings in truth bear the marks of bodhi”. (Watson 1997, 53) 「若彌勒得阿耨多羅三藐三菩提者,一切眾生皆亦應得。所以者何?一切眾生即菩提相。」《菩薩品第四》T14, no. 0475, p. 0542a34-35.
viii“You are in this immediate present born, aged, and extinguished”. (McRae , 97) 「汝今即時,亦生亦老亦滅。」《菩薩品第四》T14, no. 0475, p. 0542a31.
ix“All things are just the same – they have no fixed form”. (Watson 1997, 91) 「一切諸法亦復如是,無有定相。」《觀眾生品第七》T14, no. 0475, p. 0548b26.
x“As if he were a magician seeing a conjured person, so should a bodhisattva view sentient beings, like a wise person seeing the moon in water, like seeing the image of a face in a mirror, like a mirage when it is hot, like the echo of a shout, like clouds in the sky, like water collecting into foam, like bubbles upon water, like the firmness of the banana tree, like the prolonged abiding of lightning, …”(McRae , 123) 「譬如幻師,見所幻人,菩薩觀眾生為若此。如智者見水中月,如鏡中見其面像,如熱時焰,如呼聲響,如空中雲,如水聚沫,如水上泡,如芭蕉堅,如電久住,…」《觀眾生品第七》T14, no. 0475, p. 0547b01-02.
xi「是身不淨,穢惡充滿。」《方便品第二》T14, no. 0475, p. 0539b16.
xii“stubborn and strong-willed beings who are difficult to convert” (Watson 1997, 118) 「剛強難化眾生。」《香積佛品第十》T14, no. 0475, p. 0552c33.
xiii“When the mind is pure, the Buddha land will be pure”. (Watson 1997, 29) 「隨其心淨,則佛土淨。」《佛國品第一》T14, no. 0475, p. 0538b29.
xiv“The Buddha explains the Dharma with one sound, and sentient beings each attain understanding according to their capacity”. (Watson 1997, 74) 「佛以一音演說法,眾生隨類各得解。」《佛國品第一》T14, no. 0475, p. 0537b53; “The Buddha preaches the Law with a single voice, but each living being understands it in his own way”. (Watson 1997, 24) 「佛以一音演說法,眾生各各隨所解。」《佛國品第一》T14, no. 0475, p. 0537b55.
xv「五濁惡世。」《香積佛品第十》T14, no. 0475, p. 0552b09.
xvi“The sentient beings of this land are obdurate and difficult to convert”. (McRae , 153) 「此土眾生剛強難化。」《香積佛品第十》T14, no. 0475, p. 0552c26.
xvii“These people who are difficult to convert have minds like monkeys”. (Watson 1997, 118) 「以難化之人,心如猨猴。」《香積佛品第十》T14, no. 0475, p. 0552c32.
xviii“All things in the phenomenal world are just such phantoms and conjured beings”. (Watson 1997, 43) 「一切諸法,如幻化相。」《弟子品第三》T14, no. 0475, p. 0540b28.
xix“The non-abiding is its fundamental basis. … All dharmas are established on the fundamental [basis] of non-abiding.” (McRae , 127) 「無住則無本。… 從無住本,立一切法。」《觀眾生品第七》T14, no. 0475, p. 0547c21.
xx「諸法究竟無所有,是空義。」《弟子品第三》T14, no. 0475, p. 0541a14.
xxi“Form is emptiness – it is not that form extinguishes emptiness but that the nature of form is of itself empty”. (McRae , 145) 「色即是空,非色滅空,色性自空。」《入不二法門品第九》T14, no. 0475, 0551a19.
xxii“… understand that all phenomena are no more than phantom forms”. (Watson 1997, 40) 「知諸法如幻相;無自性,無他性。」《弟子品第三》T14, no. 0475, p. 0540a28.
xxiii“All the dharmas are generated and extinguished, without abiding. Like phantasms or lightning bolts, the dharmas do not depend on each other. They do not abide even for a single instant. The dharmas are all false views, like a dream, like a mirage, like the moon [reflected] in water, like an image in a mirror – [all] generated from false conceptualization”. (McRae , 93) 「一切法生滅不住,如幻如電,諸法不相待,乃至一念不住;諸法皆妄見,如夢、如炎、如水中月、如鏡中像,以妄想生。」《弟子品第三》T14, no. 0475, p. 0541b16-17.
xxiv“The nature of those transgressions does not reside within, it does not reside without, and it does not reside in the middle. … The mind likewise does not reside within, does not reside without, and does not reside in the middle. Just so is the mind, and just so are transgression and defilement. The dharmas are also likewise, in not transcending suchness”. (McRae , 93) 「彼罪性不在內、不在外、不在中間,…心亦不在內、不在外、不在中間,如其心然,罪垢亦然,諸法亦然,不出於如。」《弟子品第三》T14, no. 0475, p. 0541b12-14.
xxv“All things are impermanent in nature”. (Watson 1997, 31) 「知有為法皆悉無常。」《佛國品第一》T14, no. 0475, p. 0538c30.
xxvi“Emptiness is none other than formlessness”. (Watson 1997, 108) 「空即無相。」《入不二法門品第九》T14, no. 0475, p. 0551b07.
xxvii“The body is impermanent”. (McRae , 110) 「說身無常。」《文殊師利問疾品第五》T14, no. 0475, p. 0544c18.
xxviii“This body is insubstantial, being housed in the four elements”. (McRae , 83) 「是身不實,四大為家。」《方便品第二》T14, no. 0475, p. 0539b15.
xxix「譬如幻師,見所幻人,菩薩觀眾生為若此。如智者見水中月,如鏡中見其面像,如熱時焰,如呼聲響,如空中雲,如水聚沫,如水上泡,如芭蕉堅,如電久住,…」《觀眾生品第七》T14, no. 0475, p. 0548b01-02.
xxx“This body is like an echo, dependent on causes and conditions”. (McRae , 83) 「是身如響,屬諸因緣。」《方便品第二》T14, no. 0475, p. 0539b14.
xxxi“Phantoms have no fixed form. … All things are just the same – they have no fixed form”. (Watson 1997, 90–91) 「幻無定相,… 一切諸法亦復如是,無有定相。」《觀眾生品第七》T14, no. 0475, p. 0548b25-26.
xxxii“Sentient beings are likewise without death and birth”. (McRae , 131) 「眾生猶然,無沒生也。」《觀眾生品第七》T14, no. 0475, p. 0548c11.
xxxiii「五欲無常。」《菩薩品第四》T14, no. 0475, p. 0543a12.
xxxiv“This body is without self, like fire”. (McRae , 83) 「是身無我,為如火。」《方便品第二》T14, no. 0475, p. 0539b14-15.
xxxv“The body is without ego”. (Watson 1997, 67) 「說身無我。」《文殊師利問疾品第五》T14, no. 0475, p. 0544c18.
xxxvi“no ‘I’, no doer, no recipient” (Watson 1997, 22) 「無我無造無受者。」《佛國品第一》T14, no. 0475, p. 0537b38.
xxxvii“There is no self in the self, yet no duality: this is the meaning of non-self.” (McRae , 91) 「於我、無我而不二,是無我義。」《弟子品第三》T14, no. 0475, p. 0541a15.
xxxviii“This body is like a shadow, manifested through karmic conditions”. (McRae , 83) 「是身如影,從業緣現。」《方便品第二》T14, no. 0475, p. 0539b13-14.
xxxix“Yet good and bad karma never cease to function”. (Watson 1997, 22) 「善惡之業亦不亡。」《佛國品第一》T14, no. 0475, p. 0537b38.
xl“These are misdeeds of the body; these are the retribution for misdeeds of the body. These are misdeeds of the mouth; these are the retribution for misdeeds of the mouth. These are misdeeds of the mind; these are the retribution for misdeeds of the mind. This is the killing of living beings; this is the retribution for killing living beings. This is taking what has not been given to you; this is the retribution for taking what has not been given to you. This is sexual misconduct; this is the retribution for sexual misconduct. This is lying; this is the retribution for lying. This is being double-tongued; this is the retribution for being double-tongued. This is harsh speech; this is the retribution for harsh speech. This is specious talk; this is the retribution for specious talk. This is greed; this is the retribution for greed. This is wrath; this is the retribution for wrath. These are erroneous views; this is the retribution for erroneous views. This is stinginess; this is the retribution for stinginess. This is breaking the precepts; this is the retribution for breaking the precepts. This is anger; this is the retribution for anger. This is sloth this is the retribution for sloth. This is distractedness; this is the retribution for distractedness. This is stupidity; this is the retribution for stupidity”. (Watson 1997, 117–118) 「是身邪行,是身邪行報;是口邪行,是口邪行報;是意邪行,是意邪行報;是殺生,是殺生報;是不與取,是不與取報;是邪婬,是邪婬報;是妄語,是妄語報;是兩舌,是兩舌報;是惡口,是惡口報;是無義語,是無義語報;是貪嫉,是貪嫉報;是瞋惱,是瞋惱報;是邪見,是邪見報;是慳悋,是慳悋報;是毀戒,是毀戒報;是瞋恚,是瞋恚報;是懈怠,是懈怠報;是亂意,是亂意報;是愚癡,是愚癡報。」《香積佛品第十》T14, no. 0475, p. 552c27-29.
xli“the sufferings of the body” (Watson 1997, 67)「說身有苦。」《文殊師利問疾品第五》T14, no. 0475, p. 0544c18.
xlii“the innumerable kalpas of suffering of one’s past lives” (McRae , 110) 「宿世無數劫苦。」《文殊師利問疾品第五》T14, no. 0475, p. 0544c19.
xliii“The five components are wide open, empty, nothing arising in them – this is the meaning of suffering”. (Watson 1997, 45) 「五受陰,洞達空無所起,是苦義。」《弟子品第三》T14, no. 0475, p. 0541a13.
xliv「一切所有施於彼者,是為菩薩。」《菩薩品第四》T14, no. 0475, p. 0543b13.
xlv“and while the bodhisattva is in the realm of birth and death he does not scorn their company” (Watson 1997, 66) 「菩薩於生死而不捨。」《文殊師利問疾品第五》T14, no. 0475, p. 0544c07.
xlvi“to bear the burden of all [sentient beings] using the dharmas of birth” (McRae , 163) 「以生法荷負一切。」《菩薩行品第十一》T14, no. 0475, p. 0554c05.
xlvii「阿耨多羅三藐三菩提心」《佛國品第一》T14, no. 0475, p. 0538c29.
xlviii「大乘心」《弟子品第三》T14, no. 0475, p. 0540c26.
xlix「行菩薩慈,安眾生故。」《觀眾生品第七》T14, no. 0475, p. 0547b16-17.
l「以救眾生,起大悲心。」《菩薩品第四》T14, no. 0475, p. 0543c05-06.
li「不著己樂,慶於彼樂。」《菩薩行品第十一》T14, no. 0475, p. 0554b09.
lii「捨諸所有。」《菩薩行品第十一》T14, no. 0475, p. 0554b09-10.
liii“the Dharma of universal sameness” (McRae , 87) 「平等法」《弟子品第三》T14, no. 0475, p. 0540a26.
liv“identical with living beings, free of distinctions with regard to things” (Watson 1997, 131) 「同眾生,於諸法無分別。」《見阿閦佛品第十二》T14, no. 0475, p. 0554c36-37.
lv「饒益眾生。」《方便品第二》T14, no. 0475, p. 0539a20.
lvi“do away with the ills that afflict all living beings” (Watson 1997, 36) 「斷一切眾生病。」《方便品第二》T14, no. 0475, p. 0539b33.
lvii“cut off the source of illness” (Watson 1997, 69) 「斷病本。」《文殊師利問疾品第五》T14, no. 0475, p. 0545a15.
lviiiThe term “altruism” was coined by Comte (, 18).
lix“to enable all living beings to acquire a clean and pure land” (Watson 1997, 135) 「願使一切眾生得清淨土。」《見阿閦佛品第十二》T14, no. 0475, p. 0555c17.
lx“releasing the bonds of sentient beings” (McRae , 105) 「解眾生縛。」《菩薩品第四》T14, no. 0475, p. 0543c11.
lxi“causing innumerable thousands of people to all generate the intention to achieve anuttarā-samyak-sa ṃbodhi” (McRae , 84) 「令無數千人皆發阿耨多羅三藐三菩提心。」《方便品第二》T14, no. 0475, p. 0539c11.
lxii「當作醫王,療治眾病。」《文殊師利問疾品第五》T14, no. 0475, p. 0544c20.
lxiii“The inexhaustible lamp is like a lamp that ignites a hundred thousand lamps, illuminating all darkness with an illumination that is never exhausted. …, if a single bodhisattva guides a hundred thousand sentient beings, causing them to generate the intention to achieve anuttarā-samyak-sa ṃbodhi, that bodhisattva’s intention to achieve enlightenment will also never be extinguished”. (McRae , 103) 「無盡燈者,譬如一燈,燃百千燈,冥者皆明,明終不盡。如是,諸姊!夫一菩薩開導百千眾生,令發阿耨多羅三藐三菩提心,於其道意亦不滅盡。」《菩薩品第四》T14, no. 0475, p. 0543b16-17.
lxiv「大導師」《佛國品第一》T14, no. 0475, p. 0537b59.
lxv「因以解人惑。」《佛道品第八》T14, no. 0475, p. 0549b73.
lxvi“guiding living beings” (Watson 1997, 127) 「引導眾生。」《菩薩行品第十一》T14, no. 0475, p. 0554b14.
lxvii「直心」《佛國品第一》T14, no. 0475, p. 0538a29.
lxviii「深心」《佛國品第一》T14, no. 0475, p. 0538a29.
lxix「當淨其心。」《佛國品第一》T14, no. 0475, p. 0538b29.
lxx「平等無二。」《入不二法門品第九》T14, no. 0475, p. 0551a16.
lxxi“To have false concepts is defilement; to be without false concepts is purity. Confusion is defilement, and the absence of confusion is purity. To grasp the self is defilement, and not to grasp the self is purity”. (McRae , 93) 「妄想是垢,無妄想是淨;顛倒是垢,無顛倒是淨;取我是垢,不取我是淨。」《弟子品第三》T14, no. 0475, p. 0541b15-16.
lxxii「愛見悲」《文殊師利問疾品第五》T14, no. 0475, p. 0545a26.
lxxiii“To contemplate the body as impermanent suffering, empty, and non-self is called wisdom”. (McRae , 113) 「又復觀身無常、苦、空、非我,是名為慧。」《文殊師利問疾品第五》T14, no. 0475, p. 0545a33-34.
lxxiv“Although the body is ill, it always exists in sa ṃsāra. To benefit all without tiring – this is called skilful means”. (McRae , 113) 「雖身有疾,常在生死,饒益一切,而不厭倦,是名方便。」《文殊師利問疾品第五》T14, no. 0475, p. 0545a34.
lxxv“It means that, with a mind free of affection and concern, a bodhisattva sets about to adorn the Buddha lands, lead numerous living beings to them, and regulate himself with the doctrines of emptiness, formlessness, and nonaction, never experiencing weariness or revulsion. This is called the liberation of wisdom with expedient means”. (Watson 1997, 71) 「謂不以愛見心莊嚴佛土、成就眾生,於空、無相、無作法中,以自調伏,而不疲厭,是名有方便慧解。」《文殊師利問疾品第五》T14, no. 0475, p. 0545a30-31.
lxxvi“Though he moves in the realm of formlessness he yet saves many living beings”. (Watson 1997, 73) 「雖行無相,而度眾生。」《文殊師利問疾品第五》T14, no. 0475, p. 0545b28.
lxxvii“Though he addresses himself to all living beings he does so without affection or attachment”. (Watson 1997, 72) 「雖攝一切眾生,而不愛著。」《文殊師利問疾品第五》T14, no. 0475, p. 0545b27.
lxxviii「縛」《文殊師利問疾品第五》T14, no. 0475, p. 0545a27.
lxxix「煩惱」《文殊師利問疾品第五》T14, no. 0475, p. 0545a26.
lxxx「惱」《方便品第二》T14, no. 0475, p. 0539b12.
lxxxi「從癡有愛。」《文殊師利問疾品第五》T14, no. 0475, p. 0544b20.
lxxxii「身」《觀眾生品第七》T14, no. 0475, p. 0547c17.
lxxxiii“Alternately suffering and vexatious, it accumulates a host of illnesses”. (McRae , 83) 「為苦、為惱,眾病所集。」《方便品第二》T14, no. 0475, p. 0539b12.
lxxxiv「又此病起,皆由著我。」《文殊師利問疾品第五》T14, no. 0475, p. 0544c28.
lxxxv「欲貪」《觀眾生品第七》T14, no. 0475, p. 0547c17.
lxxxvi「從有攀緣,則為病本。」《文殊師利問疾品第五》T14, no. 0475, p. 0545a16.
lxxxvii「顛倒」《文殊師利問疾品第五》T14, no. 0475, p. 0544c30.
lxxxviii「虛妄分別」《觀眾生品第七》T14, no. 0475, p. 0547c18.
lxxxix“Non-duality is bodhi”. (McRae , 98) 「不二是菩提。」《菩薩品第四》T14, no. 0475, p. 0542a39-40.
xc“Birth and extinction form a dualism. But since all dharmas are not born to begin with, they must now be without extinction. By grasping and learning to accept this truth of birthlessness one may enter the gate of no-dualism.” (Watson 1997, 104) 「生滅為二。法本不生,今則無滅,得此無生法忍,是為入不二法門。」《入不二法門品第九》T14, no. 0475, p. 0550c1-2.
xci“Defilement and purity constitute a duality. If one sees the real nature of defilement, then there is no characteristic of purity, and one accords with the extinction of characteristics. This is to enter the Dharma gate of non-duality”. (McRae , 143) 「垢、淨為二。見垢實性,則無淨相,順於滅相,是為入不二法門。」《入不二法門品第九》T14, no. 0475, p. 0550c11.
xcii“What is good and what is not good constitute a duality. If one does not generate the good and what is not good, entering into and penetrating the limit of the non-characteristics, this is to enter the Dharma gate of non-duality”. (McRae , 144) 「善、不善為二。若不起善、不善,入無相際而通達者,是為入不二法門。」《入不二法門品第九》T14, no. 0475, p. 0550c22.
xciii“Transgression and blessing constitute a duality. If one penetrates the nature of transgression, then it is not different from blessings. Using the vajra wisdom to definitively comprehend this characteristic, and to be neither in bondage nor emancipated, is to enter the Dharma gate of non-duality”. (McRae , 144) 「罪、福為二。若達罪性,則與福無異,以金剛慧決了此相,無縛無解者,是為入不二法門。」《入不二法門品第九》T14, no. 0475, p. 0550c24-25.
xciv“It is without ties or attachments, without personal possessions, without thought of possessions, without fluster or confusion. It means harbouring joy within”. (Watson 1997, 49) 「無繫著;無我所,無所受;無擾亂,內懷喜。」《弟子品第三》T14, no. 0475, p. 0541c12.
xcv“Because their offense by its nature does not exist either inside them, or outside, or in between. … When the mind is pure, the living being will be pure. As the mind is, so will be the offense or defilement. The same is true of all things, for none escape the realm of Suchness. … In the same way, when all living beings gain an understanding of the nature of the mind, the no defilement exists. Where there is no topsy-turvy thinking, that is purity. Belief in the self is defilement. Where there is no such belief, that is purity. … All phenomena are born and pass into extinction never enduring, like phantoms, like lightning. … One who understands this is called a keeper of the precepts, one who understands this is called well liberated”. (Watson 1997, 47) 「彼罪性不在內、不在外、不在中間,如佛所說,心垢故眾生垢,心淨故眾生淨。心亦不在內、不在外、不在中間,如其心然,罪垢亦然,諸法亦然,不出於如。…妄想是垢,無妄想是淨;顛倒是垢,無顛倒是淨;取我是垢,不取我是淨。… 一切法生滅不住,如幻如電。…其知此者,是名奉律;其知此者,是名善解。」《弟子品第三》T14, no. 0475, p. 0541b12-17.
xcvi“Non-grasping is bodhi”. (McRae , 99) 「無取是菩提。」《菩薩品第四》T14, no. 0475, p. 0542a42.
xcvii 「但除其病,而不除法。」《文殊師利問疾品第五》T14, no. 0475, p. 0545a15.
xcviii“neither possesses earthly desires nor is separated from earthly desires” (Watson 1997, 41) 「非有煩惱,非離煩惱。」《弟子品第三》T14, no. 0475, p. 0540a29-30.
xcix“not to eradicate the afflictions yet enter into nirvā ṇ a” (McRae , p. 85) 「不斷煩惱而入涅槃。」《弟子品第三》T14, no. 0475, p. 0539b20.
c“All the afflictions constitute the seed of the Tathāgata”. (McRae , 135) 「一切煩惱,為如來種。」《佛道品第八》T14, no. 0475, p. 0549b07.
ci“The field of the sensory troubles constitutes the seed of the Tathāgata”. (McRae , 135) 「塵勞之疇為如來種。」《佛道品第八》T14, no. 0475, p. 0549b16.
cii“If you do not descend into the vast ocean, you can never acquire a priceless pearl. In the same way, if you do not enter the great sea of earthly desires, you can never acquire the treasure of comprehensive wisdom”. (Watson 1997, 95–96) 「譬如不下巨海,不能得無價寶珠。如是不入煩惱大海,則不能得一切智寶。」《佛道品第八》T14, no. 0475, p. 0549b7-8.
ciii“Hindrances are bodhi”. (McRae , 98) 「障是菩提。」《菩薩品第四》T14, no. 0475, p. 0542a38.
civ“Wanting to save people, [Vimalakīrti] used his excellent skilful means”. (McRae , 81) 「欲度人故,以善方便。」《方便品第二》T14, no. 0475, p. 0539a11.
cv“Skilful means are the place of enlightenment, because of the salvation of sentient beings”. (McRae , 100) 「方便是道場,教化眾生故。」《菩薩品第四》T14, no. 0475, p. 0542c15.
cvi“Bodhisattvas acquire the budhha lands according to the sentient beings they convert. They acquire the buddha lands according to the sentient beings they discipline. They acquire the buddha lands according to what country sentient beings need to enter into buddha wisdom. They acquire the buddha lands according to what country sentient beings need to generate the roots [for becoming] bodhisattvas”. (McRae , 75) 「菩薩隨所化眾生而取佛土,隨所調伏眾生而取佛土,隨諸眾生應以何國入佛智慧而取佛土,隨諸眾生應以何國起菩薩根而取佛土。」《佛國品第一》T14, no. 0475, p. 0538a21-22.
cvii“Because the bodhisattva’s acquisition of a pure land is wholly due to his having brought benefit to living beings”. (Watson 1997, 26) 「菩薩取於淨國,皆為饒益諸眾生故。」《佛國品第一》T14, no. 0475, p. 0538a22-23.
cviii“to enable all living beings to acquire a clean and pure land” (Watson 1997, 135) 「願使一切眾生得清淨土。」《見阿閦佛品第十二》T14, no. 0475, p. 0555c17.
cix“If one wishes to save sentient beings, the afflictions should be eradicated”. (McRae , 126) 「欲度眾生,除其煩惱。」《觀眾生品第七》T14, no. 0475, p. 0547c12.
cx“In accordance with the needs of others, he causes them to enter into the path of buddhahood. Using the power of good skilful means, he provides sufficiency to all”. (McRae , 141)「隨彼之所須,得入於佛道,以善方便力,皆能給足之。」《佛道品第八》T14, no. 0475, p. 0549b105-106.
cxi“The Thus Come One in our land does not employ words in his exposition. He just uses various fragrances to induce heavenly and human beings to undertake the observance of the precepts”. (Watson 1997, 117) 「我土如來無文字說,但以眾香令諸天、人得入律行。」《香積佛品第十》T14, no. 0475, p. 0552c22.
cxii“first enticing them with desire, and later causing them to enter the wisdom of the Buddha”. (McRae , 140) 「先以欲鉤牽,後令入佛道。」《佛道品第八》T14, no. 0475, p. 0549b97.
cxiii“This body is like earth that has no subjective being”. (Watson 1997, 35) 「是身無主,為如地。」《方便品第二》T14, no. 0475, p. 0539b14.
cxiv“This body is impermanent, without durability, without strength, without firmness, a thing that decays in a moment, not to be relied on”. (Watson 1997, 34) 「是身無常、無強、無力、無堅、速朽之法,不可信也!」《方便品第二》T14, no. 0475, p. 0539b11-12.
cxv“This body is like a dream, an illusory view. … This body is without lifespan, like the wind”. (McRae , 83) 「是身如夢,為虛妄見;… 是身無壽,為如風。」《方便品第二》T14, no. 0475, p. 0539b13-15.
cxvi“This illness of mine is born of ignorance and feelings of attachment”. (Watson 1997, 65) 「從癡有愛,則我病生。」《文殊師利問疾品第五》T14, no. 0475, p. 0544b20.
cxvii“It is through objectified mentation that the basis of illness is constituted”. (McRae , 111) 「從有攀緣,則為病本。」《文殊師利問疾品第五》T14, no. 0475, p. 0545a16.
cxviii“It is just as lotus flowers do not grow on dry land on the high plateau – these flowers grow in the muddy filth of the lowly marshes. … It is like planting is seed in space, where it would never grow – only in nightsoil-enriched earth can it flourish”. (McRae , 135) 「譬如高原陸地,不生蓮華,卑濕淤泥乃生此華;… 糞壤之地,乃能滋茂。」《佛道品第八》T14, no. 0475, p. 0549b04-06.
cxix“The inexhaustible lamp is like a lamp that ignites a hundred thousand lamps, illuminating all darkness with an illumination that is never exhausted”. (McRae , 103) 「無盡燈者,譬如一燈,燃百千燈,冥者皆明,明終不盡。」《菩薩品第四》T14, no. 0475, p. 0543b15.
cxx“As if he were a magician seeing a conjured person, so should a bodhisattva view sentient beings. Like a wise person seeing the moon in water, lie a mirage when it is hot, like …”(McRae , 123) 「譬如幻師,見所幻人,菩薩觀眾生為若此。如智者見水中月,如鏡中見其面像,如熱時焰,…」《觀眾生品第七》T14, no. 0475, p. 0547b01-05.
cxxi“There are [other buddha lands] where dreams, phantasms, shadows, echoes, images in mirrors, the moon [reflected in] water, mirages during times of heat, and other metaphors perform the Buddha’s work”. (McRae , 159) 「有以夢、幻、影、響、鏡中像、水中月、熱時炎,如是等喻而作佛事。」《菩薩行品第十一》T14, no. 0475, p. 0554c18-19.
cxxii“At that time the goddess employed her supernatural powers to change Śāriputra into a goddess like herself, while she took on Śāriputra’s form. Then she asked, ‘Why don’t you change out of this female body?’ Śāriputra, now in the form of a goddess, replied ‘I don’t know why I have suddenly changed and taken on a female body’”. (Watson 1997, 91) 「即時天女以神通力,變舍利弗令如天女,天自化身如舍利弗,而問言:何以不轉女身?舍利弗以天女像而答言:「我今不知何轉而變為女身?」《觀眾生品第七》T14, no. 0475, p. 0548b47-49.
cxxiii“His (the Buddha) lion seat is eight-four thousand yojanas high … Buddha dispatched thirty-two thousand lion seats, tall, wide, and pure in ornamentation, which arrived in Vimalakīrti’s room. … The breath of the room entirely accommodated the thirty-two thousand lion seats with no obstruction”. (McRae , 118–119) 「其師子座高八萬四千由旬,嚴飾第一。…即時彼佛遣三萬二千師子座,高廣嚴淨,來入維摩詰室,…其室廣博,悉皆包容三萬二千師子座,無所妨礙。」《不思議品第六》T14, no. 0475, p. 0546b02-06.
cxxiv“Vimalakīrti said, ‘O Śāriputra, the buddhas and bodhisattvas have an emancipation called inconceivable. For a bodhisattva residing in this emancipation the vastness of [Mount] Sumeru can be placed within a mustard seed without [either of them] increasing or decreasing in size. Sumeru, king of mountains will remain in appearance as before, …” (McRae , 119) 「以須彌之高廣內芥子中無所增減,須彌山王本相如故。」《不思議品第六》T14, no. 0475, p. 0546b24-25.
cxxv“take the waters of the four great oceans and pour them into the opening that holds a single hair” (Watson 1997, 78) 「又以四大海水入一毛孔。」《不思議品第六》T14, no. 0475, p. 0546b26.
cxxvi“It is as the layman has said. But the Buddha has appeared in this evil world of five impurities and at present is practising the Law so as to save and liberate living beings”. (Watson 1997, 50–51) 「如居士言。但為佛出五濁惡世,現行斯法,度脫眾生。」《弟子品第三》T14, no. 0475, p. 0542a09.
cxxvii“At that time the bodhisattvas who had come from the Host of Fragrances world held their palms together and addressed the Buddha, ‘World-honoured One, when we first saw this land we generated the concept of its inferiority. Now we are ashamed of ourselves and have abandoned this attitude. Why? The skilful means of the buddhas are inconceivable. In order to save sentient beings, they manifest different buddha countries in accordance with the responses of [sentient beings]”. (McRae , 161) 「爾時眾香世界菩薩來者,合掌白佛言:「世尊!我等初見此土,生下劣想,今自悔責,捨離是心。所以者何?諸佛方便,不可思議!為度眾生故,隨其所應,現佛國異。」《菩薩行品第十一》T14, no. 0475, p. 0554a28-29.
cxxviii“Even were the four seas to dry up, this food would not be exhausted”. (McRae , 152) 「四海有竭,此飯無盡。」《香積佛品第十》T14, no. 0475, p. 0552c10-11.
cxxix“All living beings are a part of Suchness and all other things as well are a part of Suchness. The sages and worthy ones too are a part of Suchness; even you, Maitreya, are a part of Suchness. So if you have been given a prophecy of enlightenment, then all living beings should likewise be given such a prophecy. Why? Because Suchness knows no dualism or differentiation. If you, Maitreya, are able to attain anuttarā-samyak-sa ṃ bodhi, then all living beings should likewise be able to attain it. Why? Because all living beings should likewise be able to attain it. Why? Because all living beings in truth bear the marks of bodhi”. (Watson 1997, 53) 「一切眾生皆如也,一切法亦如也,眾聖賢亦如也,至於彌勒亦如也。若彌勒得受記者,一切眾生亦應受記。所以者何?夫如者不二不異,若彌勒得阿耨多羅三藐三菩提者,一切眾生皆亦應得。所以者何?一切眾生即菩提相。」《菩薩品第四》T14, no. 0475, p. 0542a33-35.
cxxx“At that time, the goddess asked Śāriputra, ‘Why would you remove the flowers?’ [Śāriputra] answered, ‘Theses flowers are contrary to the Dharma, so I would remove them.’ The goddess said, ‘Do not say that these flowers are contrary to the Dharma! Why? These flowers are without discrimination. Sir, it is you who are generating discriminative thoughts’”. (McRae , 127) 「爾時天女問舍利弗:何故去華?答曰:此華不如法,是以去之。天曰:勿謂此華為不如法。所以者何?是華無所分別,仁者自生分別想耳!」《觀眾生品第七》T14, no. 0475, p. 0547c24-28.
cxxxi“At this point Vimalakīrti was silent, saying nothing. Mañjuśrī exclaimed, ‘Excellent, excellent! Not to even have words or speech is the true entrance into the Dharma gate of nonduality’”. (McRae , 148) 「時維摩詰默然無言。文殊師利歎曰:善哉!善哉!乃至無有文字、語言,是真入不二法門。」《入不二法門品第九》T14, no. 0475, p. 0551c22-23.
cxxxii“The inexhaustible lamp is like a lamp that ignites a hundred thousand lamps, illuminating all darkness with an illumination that is never exhausted. Thus, sisters, if a single bodhisattva guides a hundred thousand sentient beings, causing them to generate the intention to achieve anuttarā-samyak-sa ṃ bodhi, that bodhisattva’s intention to achieve enlightenment will also never be extinguished. With each teaching of the Dharma all the good dharmas are naturally increased. This is what is called the ‘inexhaustible lamp’. Although you reside in Māra’s palace, with this inexhaustible lamp you can cause innumerable gods and goddesses to generate the intention to achieve anuttarā-samyak-sa ṃbodhi. Thereby you will repay the Buddha’s kindness and also greatly benefit all sentient beings”. (McRae , 103) 「無盡燈者,譬如一燈,燃百千燈,冥者皆明,明終不盡。如是,諸姊!夫一菩薩開導百千眾生,令發阿耨多羅三藐三菩提心,於其道意亦不滅盡,隨所說法,而自增益一切善法,是名無盡燈也。汝等雖住魔宮,以是無盡燈,令無數天子天女,發阿耨多羅三藐三菩提心者,為報佛恩,亦大饒益一切眾生。」《菩薩品第四》T14, no. 0475, p. 0543b15-17.
cxxxiii“At the time, there was a goddess in Vimalakīrti’s room who, upon seeing the great men listening to the Dharma being explained, made herself visible and scattered heavenly flowers over the bodhisattvas and great disciples. When the flowers reached the bodhisattvas they all immediately fell off, but when they reached the great disciples they adhered and did not fall off”. (McRae , 127) 「時維摩詰室有一天女,見諸大人聞所說法,便現其身,即以天華,散諸菩薩、大弟子上。華至諸菩薩,即皆墮落,至大弟子,便著不墮。」《觀眾生品第七》T14, no. 0475, p. 0547c23-24.
cxxxiv“Vimalakīrti used to occasion of his illness to make extensive explanations of the Dharma”. (McRae , 83) 「維摩詰因以身疾,廣為說法。」《方便品第二》T14, no. 0475, p. 0539b11.
cxxxv“Using skilful means he manifested becoming ill himself”. (McRae , 83) 「其以方便,現身有疾。」《方便品第二》T14, no. 0475, p. 0539b10.
cxxxvi“If he went to gambling houses or theatres it was only to save people. … In entering the brothels, he revealed the transgressions [that arise from] desire. In entering the wine shops, he was able to maintain his [good] intention”. (McRae , 82) 「若至博弈戲處,輒以度人;…入諸婬舍,示欲之過;入諸酒肆,能立其志。」《方便品第二》T14, no. 0475, p. 0539a14-15.
cxxxvii“When he was among the common people as the most honoured among the common people he had them generate the power of blessings”. (McRae , 82) 「若在庶民,庶民中尊,令興福力。」《方便品第二》T14, no. 0475, p. 0539a18.
cxxxviii“With the sword of wisdom one will destroy the ‘bandits’ of the afflictions”. (McRae , 162) 「以智慧劍,破煩惱賊。」《菩薩行品第十一》T14, no. 0475, p. 0554b12.
Fung Kei Cheng, PhD, focuses on applying Chinese Buddhism to various disciplines, including counselling, mental health, complementary and alternative medicine, conflict resolution, business management, gender studies, and sustainable development. Correspondence: firstname.lastname@example.org.
Samson Tse, PhD, is Professor in Department of Social Work and Social Administration, The University of Hong Kong. He is specialised in mental health, including addiction.
We convey our deep gratitude to the 38 participants, who have openly shared their personal experiences and ideas with us. Our thankfulness is also directed towards Dr Sandra Tsang (曾潔雯博士) for her assistance in recruiting participants; Dr Wei Rui Xiong (熊偉銳博士), the peer analyst; Mr Lozang Hau (侯松蔚先生), the Tibetan interpreter; the anonymous translator who proofreads the translated verbatim narratives; and Professor Jian Ping He (何劍平教授), and Dr Xin Shiu Wang (王新水博士) for their suggestions on the earlier draft of this manuscript.
- Abe M: Zen and comparative studies: Part two of a two-volume sequel to Zen and western thought. University of Hawai'i Press, Honolulu: USA; 1997.Google Scholar
- Abiko H: The aspect of great joy. The Pacific World Journal: Journal of Institute of Buddhist Studies no. 1982,1(1):8.Google Scholar
- Akizuki R: New Mahāyāna: Buddhism for a post-modern world. Asian Humanities Press, Translated by James W. Heisg and Paul L. Swanson. California; 1990.Google Scholar
- App U: Arthur Schopenhauer and China: A Sino-Platonic love affair. Sino-Platonic Papers, Department of East Asian Languages and Civilizations, University of Pennsylvania, USA; 2010.Google Scholar
- Arthur CJ: Phenomenology of relgion and the art of story-telling: The relevance of William Golding’s ‘the inheritors’ to religious studies. Religious Studies no. 1987, 23: 59–79.Google Scholar
- Averill JR: On art, science, metaphors, and ghosts: A few thoughts to share. Emotion Review no. 2009,1(1):88–89.Google Scholar
- Bakes, and S Alan. 2012. "Helpful strategies for teaching effective confrontation skills". Ideas and Research You Can Use: VISTAS 2012 no. 1 (Article 36) ., [http://counselingoutfitters.com/vistas/vistas12/Article_36.pdf]
- Bankart CP, Dockett KH, Rita Dudley-Grant G: On the path of the Buddha: A psychologists’ guide to the history of Buddhism. In Psychology and Buddhism: From individual to global community. Edited by: Dockett KH, Rita Dudley-Grant G, Peter Bankart C. Kluwer Academic/Plenum Publishers, New York; 2003:13–44.Google Scholar
- Bankart Peter C: "Mindfulness, compassion, and wisdom: Working with anger.". In Horizons in Buddhist psychology: Practice, research and theory. Edited by: Maurits G, Kwee T, Gergen KJ, Fusako K. A Taos Institute Publication, Ohio; 2006:75–83.Google Scholar
- Banman J: The use of humour in psychotherapy. International Journal for the Advancement of Counselling no. 1982,5(2):81–86.Google Scholar
- Baranowsky AB: The silencing response in clinical practice: On the road to dialogue. In Treating compassion fatigue. Edited by: Figley CR. Brunner-Routledge, New York; 2002:155–170.Google Scholar
- Basham Arthur L: "The evolution of the concept of the Bodhisattva.". In Bodhisattva doctrine in Buddhism. Edited by: Leslie K. Published for the Canadian Corporation for Studies in Religion/Corporation by Wilfred Laurier University Press, Waterloo, Ontario, Canada; 1981:19–43.Google Scholar
- Batchelor M: Introduction. In In The path of compassion: The bodhisattva percepts, 1–44. Rowman & Littlefield Publishers, Inc., UK; 2004.Google Scholar
- Bauml J, Frobose T, Kraemer S, Rentrop M, Pitschel-Walz G: Psychoeducation: A basic psychotherapeutic intervention for patients with schizophrenia and their families. Schizophrenia Bulletin no. 2006,32(S1):S1-S9.Google Scholar
- Bergson H: Laughter: An essary on the meaning of the comic. Translated by Cloudesley Brereton and Fred. Rothwell. UK, Macmillan and Company Limited; 1911.Google Scholar
- Bernhard T: How to be sick: A Buddhist-inspired guide for the chronically ill and their caregivers. Wisdom Publications, USA; 2010.Google Scholar
- Bertman SL: The arts and story: A source of comfort and insight for children who are learning about death. In Meeting the needs of our clients creatively: The impact of art and culture on caregiving. Edited by: Morgan JD. Baywood Publishing Company, Inc., New York; 2000:177–191.Google Scholar
- Beutler LE: Introduction to the special series on advances in psychotherapy process research. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology no. 1990,58(3):263–264.Google Scholar
- Bloom P: Buddhist acts of compassion. Conari Press, USA; 2000.Google Scholar
- Boeree C, George : Towards a Buddhist psychotherapy 1997 [cited July 25 2013]. 1997.Google Scholar
- Bondarenko AF: My encounter with Carl Rogers: A retrospective view from the Ukraine. Journal of Humanistic Psychology no. 1999,39(1):8–14.Google Scholar
- Boukydis K: Caring and confronting. Voices: The art and science of psychotherapy no. 1979,15(1):31–34.Google Scholar
- Brandon D: Zen in the art of helping. The Penguin Group, Great Britain; 1976/1990.Google Scholar
- Brandon D: Nowness in the helping relationship. In Awakening the heart: East/West approaches to psychotherapy and the healing relationship. Edited by: Welwood J. Shambhala Publications, Inc., USA; 1983:140–147.Google Scholar
- Bratter TE, Sinsheimer L: Confrontation: A potent psychotherapeutic approach with difficult adolescents. Adolescent Psychiatry: The Annals of the American Society for Adolescent Psychiatry no. 2008, 30: 103–116.Google Scholar
- Brems C: Basic skills in psychotherapy and counselling. Thomson/Brooks/Cole, USA; 2001.Google Scholar
- Brink DC, Farber BA: A scheme of Rogers’ clinical responses. In The psychotherapy of Carl Rogers: Cases and commentary. Edited by: Farber BA, Brink DC, Raskin PM. The Guilford Press, USA; 1996:15–24.Google Scholar
- Bronner Y: This is no lotus. It is a face: Poetics as grammer in Dandin’s investigation of the simile. In The poetics of grammar and the metaphysics of sound and sign. Edited by: La Porta S, Shulman DD. Brill, Boston; 2007:91–108.Google Scholar
- Brown O, Elkonin D, Naicker S: The use of religion and spirituality in psychotherapy: Enablers and barriers. Journal of Religion and Health no. 2013, 52: 1131–1146.Google Scholar
- Buber M: I and Thou. Translated by Ronald Gregor Smith. Morrison and Gibb Limited, UK; 1923/1937.Google Scholar
- Burns DD: Feeling good together: The secret of making troubled relationships work. Broadway Books, New York; 2008.Google Scholar
- Cade B: Treating the house like a hotel: From simile to metaphor. Case Studies in Brief and Family Therapy no. 1994,1(1):5-l4.Google Scholar
- Callow G: ‘Magician’: The use of sustained simile in the alleviation of serious behavioural disturbance and acute dyslexia in a 7-year-old boy. Contemporary Hypnosis no. 2003,20(1):40–47.Google Scholar
- Canda ER, Furman LD: Spiritual diversity in social work practice: The heart of helping. Oxford University Press, USA; 2010.Google Scholar
- Cason A, Thompson V: Working with the old and dying. In Awakening the heart: East/west approaches to psychotherapy and the healing relationship. Edited by: Welwood J. Shambhala Publications, Inc., Boston; 1983:192–201.Google Scholar
- Chang O: Buddhism and scientific methods. Hsi Lai Journal of Humanistic Buddhism no. 2007, 8: 102–114.Google Scholar
- Chen YZ, 陳燕珠 : Essential teachings of the Vimalakīrti Nirdeśa Sūtra and the Pañcavimśatisāhasrikā Prajñāpāramitā Sūtra 維摩詰經要義、心經要義. China Religious Culture Publisher 宗教文化出版社, Beijing; 2005.Google Scholar
- Cheng FK: An exploratory study of a counselling framework: Four noble truths and their multi-interactive cause-and-effect. Chung-Hwa Institute of Buddhist Studies no. 2011, 12: 151–196.Google Scholar
- Cheng Fung K, 鄭鳳姬 : Praxis of prajñā by overcoming sentimental compassion 從克服愛見悲看般空慧的實踐. Paper presented at Prajñā Conference 空慧學術會議, Hong Kong; 2013.Google Scholar
- Fung Kei Cheng, Tse S: “Just eliminate the illness; Do not eliminate dharmas”: A case study on the lived experience of a Buddhist surviving spouse. Paper presented at the 4th Asian Conference on Psychology and the Behavioural Sciences, Osaka, Japan; 2014.Google Scholar
- Ciuffardi G, Scavelli S, Leonardi A: Solution-focused brief therapy in combination with fantasy and creative language in working with children: A brief report. International Journal of Solution-Focused Practices no. 2013,1(1):44–51.Google Scholar
- Clarke JK: Utilization of clients’ metaphors to punctuate solution-focused brief therapy interventions: A case illustration. Contemporary Family Therapy 2013.Google Scholar
- Claxton G: Therapy and beyond: Concluding thoughts. In Beyond therapy: The impact of Eastern religions on psychological theory and practice. Edited by: Claxton G. Wisdom Publications, England; 1986:313–325.Google Scholar
- Comte A: System of positive polity, or treatise of sociology, instituting the religion of humanity, 4th Volume: Theory of future of man. Translated by Richard Congreve. London, Longman, Green and Company; 1854.Google Scholar
- Conze E: Buddhism: Its essence and development. London, Oxford; 1953.Google Scholar
- Conze E: Thirty years of Buddhist Studies: Selected Essays. Bruno Cassirer (Publishers) Limited, UK; 1967.Google Scholar
- Corey G: Case approach to counselling and psychotherapy. Brooks/Cole, USA; 1996.Google Scholar
- Corey G: Theory and practice of counselling and psychotherapy. Thomson/Brooks/Cole, USA; 2009.Google Scholar
- Corless R: Analogue consciousness isn’t just for faeries: Healing the disjunction between theory and practice. In American Buddhism as a way of life. Edited by: Storhoff G, Whalen-Bridge J. State University of New York Press, USA; 2010:183–194.Google Scholar
- Cornelius-White JHD: Congruence. In The handbook of person-centred psychotherapy and counselling. Edited by: Cooper M, O'Hara M, Schmid PF, Wyatt G. Palgrave Macmillan, New York; 2007:168–181.Google Scholar
- Craig SR, Chase L, Lama TN: Taking the MINI to Mustang, Nepal: Methodological and epistemological translations of an illness narrative interview tool. Anthropology and Medicine no. 2010,17(1):1–26.Google Scholar
- Crane RS, Kuyken W: The implementation of mindfulness-based cognitive therapy: Learning from the UK health service experience. Mindfulness 2012.Google Scholar
- Crawford LE: Conceptual metaphors of affect. Emotion Review no. 2009,1(2):129–139.Google Scholar
- Cui Zhong Tai 崔鍾太. 2008. "The dramatic genre of the Vimalakīrti Nirdeśa Sūtra 《維摩詰經》的戲劇體裁." Studies of Culture and Art 文化藝術研究 no. March:78–79 & 220.Google Scholar
- Dalai L: The heart of the Buddha's path. Thorsons, UK; 1999.Google Scholar
- Dao-an, Venerable 道安法師. 1997. Philosophy of śūnyata 空的哲理. Taipei: Fo Guang Shan Cultural Enterprise Limited 佛光山文化事業有限公司.Google Scholar
- Davidson IFWK, Brown WI: Using humour in counselling mentally retarded clients: A prelimiliary study. International Journal for the Advancement of Counselling no. 1989,12(2):93–104.Google Scholar
- Dayal H: The bodhisattva doctrine in Buddhist Sanskrit literature. Banarsidass Publishers Private Limited, India; 1932/1999.Google Scholar
- De Silva P: Buddhist psychology and implications for treatment. In Psychiatry and religion: Context, consensus and controversies. Edited by: Bhugra D. Routledge, London; 1996:112–124.Google Scholar
- De Silva P: The role of Buddhism in mental health in the modern world. In Buddhism and peace: Theory and practice. Edited by: Mun C. Jung Bup Sa Buddhist Temple of Hawaii, Hawaii; 2006:341–350.Google Scholar
- Han De Witt F: Working with existential and neurotic suffering. In Brilliant sanity: Buddhist approaches to psychotherapy. Edited by: Francis Kaklauskas J, Nimanheminda S, Hoffman L, MacAndrew Jack S. University of the Rockies Press, Colorado; 2008:3–17.Google Scholar
- Deeg M: Buddhist studies and its impact on Buddhism in Western societies: A historical sketch and prospects. In The role of Buddhism in the 21st century. Proceedings of the Fourth Chung-Hwa International Conference on Buddhism. Edited by: Buikkhu H. Dharma Drum Corporation, Taiwan; 2005:335–388.Google Scholar
- Sri Dhammanaha K: Buddhism for the future. The Buddha Educational Foundation, Taipei; 2000.Google Scholar
- Ding DT, 丁大同 : Buddhist joy and sorrow 佛家慈悲. Tianjin Renmin Chubanshe 天津人民出版社, China; 2009.Google Scholar
- Kathleen Dockett H, North-Schulte D: Transcending self and other: Mahāyāna principles of integration. In Psychology and Buddhism: From individual to global community. Edited by: Kathleen Dockett H, Rita Dudley-Grant G, Peter Bankart C. Kluwer Academic /Plenum Publishers, New York; 2003:215–238.Google Scholar
- Dolliver , Robert H: "Perls with Gloria re-reviewed: Gestalt techniques and Perls’s practices.". Journal of Counselling and Development 1991, 69: 299–304.Google Scholar
- Dow M: Buddhism, psychology, and neuroscience: The promises and pitfalls of a neurobiologically informed contemplative psychotherapy. In Brilliant sanity: Buddhist approaches to psychotherapy. Edited by: Francis Kaklauskas J, Nimanheminda S, Hoffman L, MacAndrew S J. University of the Rockies Press, Colorado; 2008:99–132.Google Scholar
- Dudley-Grant G, Rita C, Peter B, Dockett KH: "Introduction.". In Psychology and Buddhism: From individual to global community. Edited by: Kathleen H, Dockett G, Rita D-G, Peter Bankart C. Kluwer Academic/Plenum Publishers, New York; 2003:1–10.Google Scholar
- Dynel M: Jocker in the pack: Towards determining the status of humourous framing in conversations. In The pragmatics of humour across discourse domains. Edited by: Dynel M. John Benjamins, USA; 2011:217–242.Google Scholar
- Eatough V, Smith JA: ‘I was like a wild wild person’: Understanding feelings of anger using interpretative phenomenological analysis. British Journal of Psychology no. 2006, 97: 483–498.Google Scholar
- Egbochuku Elizabeth O: Counselling communication skills: Its place in the training programme of a counseling psychologist (pp. 17–32) 2008 [cited December 16 2013]. 2013.Google Scholar
- Emanatian M: Metaphor and the expression of emotion: The value of cross-cultural perspectives. Metaphor and Symbolic Activity no. 1995,10(3):163–182.Google Scholar
- Epstein M: Forms of emptiness: Psychodynamic, meditative and clinical perspectives. The Journal of Transpersonal Psychology no. 1989,21(1):61–71.Google Scholar
- Epstein M: Going to pieces without falling apart: A Buddhist perspective on wholeness. Thorsons, London; 1999.Google Scholar
- Epstein M: Open to desire: Embracing a lust for life: Insights from Buddhism and psychotherapy. USA, Penguin Group (USA) Inc; 2005.Google Scholar
- Fenner P: Nonduality and therapy: Awakening the unconditioned mind. In The sacred mirror: Nondual wisdom and psychotherapy. Edited by: Prendergast JJ, Fenner P, Krystal S. Paragon House, USA; 2003:23–56.Google Scholar
- Fielding RG, Llewelyn S: The new religions and psychotherapy: Similarities and differences. In Beyond therapy: The impact of Eastern religions on psychological theory and practice. Edited by: Claxton G. Wisdom Publications, England; 1986:271–289.Google Scholar
- Finlay L: Phenomenology for therapists: Researching the lived world. JohnWiley & Sons, Limited, USA; 2011.Google Scholar
- Flowers S, Stahl B: Living with your heart wide open: How mindfulness and compassion can free you from unworthiness, inadequacy and shame. New Harbinger Publications, Inc.USA; 2011.Google Scholar
- Fromm E: Foreword. In In Zen Buddhism and psychoanalysis, edited by Daisetz Teitaro Suzuki, Erich Fromm and Richard DeMartino, vii-viii. Grove Press Inc., New York; 1963.Google Scholar
- Fromm E: The nature of well-being. In Awakening the heart: East/west approaches to psychotherapy and the healing relationship. Edited by: Welwood J. Shambhala Publications, Inc., USA; 1983:59–69.Google Scholar
- Garfield SL: Issues and methods in psychotherapy process research. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology no. 1990,58(3):273–280.Google Scholar
- Gehart DR: Mindfulness and acceptance in couple and family therapy. Springer Science + Business Media, New York; 2012.Google Scholar
- Germer CK: The mindful path to self-compassion: Freeing yourself from destructive thoughts and emotions. The Guilford Press, New York; 2009.Google Scholar
- Gethin R: The foundations of Buddhism. Oxford University Press, UK; 1998.Google Scholar
- Geybels H, Van Herck W: Introduction. In Humour and religion: Challenges and ambiguities. Edited by: Geybels H, Van Herck W. Continuum International Publishing Group, New York; 2011:1–10.Google Scholar
- Glaser A: A call to compassion: Bringing Buddhist practices of the heart into the soul of psychology. Nicolas-Hays, Inc., USA; 2005.Google Scholar
- Glazer HR, Marcum D: Expressing grief throughout storytelling. Journal of Humanistic Counselling, Education and Development no. 2003,42(Fall):131–138.Google Scholar
- Vimalakīrti 維摩居士. Digital video compact disc, Taiwan; 1998.Google Scholar
- Goleman D: Mental health in classical Buddhist psychology. The Journal of Transpersonal Psychology no. 1975,7(2):176–181.Google Scholar
- Goleman D: Working with emotional intelligence. Bantam Books, USA; 1998.Google Scholar
- Goleman D: Foreword. In In Emotional awareness: Overcoming the obstacles to psychological balance and compassion: A conversation between the Dalai Lama and Paul Ekman, PhD, edited by Paul Ekman, ix-xi. Times Books, New York; 2008.Google Scholar
- Gomez LO: From the extraordinary to the ordinary: Images of the bodhisattva in East Asia. In The Christ and the bodhisattva. Edited by: Jr DL, Rockefeller SC. State University of New York Press, USA; 1987:141–191.Google Scholar
- Greene M: Using myths, legends and fairy tales in counselling: Archetypal motifs underlying the mother complex. Asia Pacific Journal of Counselling and Psychotherapy2 no 2011,2(1):41–50.Google Scholar
- Guruge Ananda WP: Buddhism and science – A century of investigation. Hsi Lai Journal of Humanistic Buddhism no. 2007, 8: 13–65.Google Scholar
- Harrison P: Who gets to ride in the great vehicle? Self-image and identity among the followers of the early Mahāyāna. The Journal of the International Assoication of Buddhist Studies no. 1987,10(1):67–89.Google Scholar
- Harvey P: An introduction to Buddhism: Teachings, history and practices. Cambridge University Press, UK; 1990.Google Scholar
- He JP, 何劍平 : Study of Vimalakīrti belief in medieval China 中國中古維摩詰信仰研究. Sichuan Publishing Group 四川出版集團, China; 2009.Google Scholar
- Heelas P, Kohn R: Psychotherapy and techniques of transformation. In Beyond therapy: The impact of Eastern religions on psychological theory and practice. Edited by: Claxton G. Wisdom Publications, England; 1986:293–309.Google Scholar
- Helm BW: Emotions as evaluative feelings. Emotion Review no. 2009,1(3):248–255.Google Scholar
- Hoffman L: An existential framework for Buddhism, world religions, and psychotherapy: Culture and diversity considerations. In Brilliant sanity: Buddhist approaches to psychotherapy. Edited by: Kaklauskas FJ, Nimanheminda S, Hoffman L, MacAndrew S J. University of the Rockies Press, Colorado; 2008:19–38.Google Scholar
- Howard A: Socrates as a role model for counsellors. Practical Philosophy no. 2011,2(1):15–17.Google Scholar
- Hsing-Yun M: The core teachings: Buddhist practice and progress 1. Translated by Rey Rong Lee and Mu Tzen Hsu. Buddha's Light Publishing, USA; 2006.Google Scholar
- Hsu HC: What is Buddhism?. Theory and practice. Translated by P. H. Wei. China, Tian Tang Shan Yuan Yin Gu Si; 2012.Google Scholar
- Huang Kuoching 黃國清: The nature and spirit of the worldly bodhisattva of the Mahāyāna Buddhism 大乘佛教久住世間的菩薩精神特質. International Journal for the Study of Humanistic Buddhism 人間佛教研究 no. 2011, 1: 111–130.Google Scholar
- Humphreys C: The wisdom of Buddhism. Curzon Press Limited, UK; 1987.Google Scholar
- Hunt D: Being intimate with what is: Healing the pain of separation. In The sacred mirror: Nondual wisdom and psychotherapy. Edited by: Prendergast JJ, Fenner P, Krystal S. Paragon House, USA; 2003:164–184.Google Scholar
- Inoue S: Putting Buddhism to work: A new approach to management and business. Translated by Duncan Ryuken Williams. USA, Kodansha International Limited; 1997.Google Scholar
- Introduction to basic counselling and communication skills. IOM training manual for migrate community leaders and community workers. International Organization for Migration, Switzerland; 2009.Google Scholar
- Johnson M: Introduction: Why metaphor matters to philosophy. Metaphor and Symbolic Activity no. 1995,10(3):157–162.Google Scholar
- Jones K: The new social face of Buddhism: A call to action. Wisdom Publications, USA; 2003.Google Scholar
- Kövecses Z: Metaphor: A practical introduction. Oxford University Press, New York; 2002.Google Scholar
- Kabat-Zinn J: Mindfulness-based interventions in context: Past, present, and future. Clinical Psychology: Science and Practice no. 2003,10(2):144–156.Google Scholar
- Kabat-Zinn J: Some reflections on the origins of MBSR, skilful means, and the trouble with maps. Contemporary Buddhism no. 2011,12(1):281–306.Google Scholar
- Kain VJ: Babies born dying: Just bad karma? A discussion paper. Journal of Religion and Health 2013. [10.1007/s10943–013–9779-x]Google Scholar
- Kaklauskas FJ, Nimanheminda S, Hoffman L, MacAndrew S J: "Introduction". In Brilliant sanity: Buddhist approaches to psychotherapy, ed. by Francis J. Kaklauskas, Susan Nimanheminda, Louise Hoffman and MacAndrew S. Jack, xix-xxii. University of the Rockies Press, Colorado; 2008.Google Scholar
- Kaklauskas FJ, Olson EA: Large group process: Grounding Buddhist and psychological theory in personal experience. In Brilliant sanity: Buddhist approaches to psychotherapy. Edited by: Kaklauskas FJ, Nimanheminda S, Hoffman L, MacAndrew S J. University of the Rockies Press, Colorado; 2008:133–160.Google Scholar
- Kanbayashi Ryuujou 神林隆淨: Study on the bodhisattva thought, Volumes 1 & 2 菩薩思想的研究上下冊. Hua Yu Publishing 華宇出版社. Original edition, Taipei; 1938/1984.Google Scholar
- Kasulis TP: "Foreword". In John W. Schroeder, Skilful means: The heart of Buddhist compassion, ix-xvii. University of Hawaii Press, USA; 2004.Google Scholar
- Kawamura LS: Facing life and death: A Buddhist understanding of palliative care and bereavement. In Meeting the needs of our clients creatively: The impact of arts and culture on caregiving. Edited by: Morgan JD. Baywood Publishing Company, New York; 2000:105–122.Google Scholar
- Kaziyama Yuuiti 梶山雄一: Wisdom of śūnyata: Modern interpretation of Prajñā Sūtra 空的智慧:般若經的現代詮釋. Translated by Qi Shi Jun 戚世俊. Yuan Ming Publisher 圓明出版社, Taipei; 1994.Google Scholar
- Keown D: Buddhism: A very short introduction. Oxford University Press, UK; 2000.Google Scholar
- Kief H: "Zen meditation as a source for therapeutic practice.". In Horizons in Buddhist psychology: Practice, research and theory. Edited by: Maurits G, Kwee T, Gergen KJ, Fusako K. A Taos Institute Publication, Ohio; 2006:119–139.Google Scholar
- Kirmayer LJ: The body’s insistence on meaning: Metaphor as presentation and representation in illness experience. Medical Anthropology Quarterly no. 1992,6(4):323–346.Google Scholar
- Klein JP: Rationality and humour in counselling. Canadian Journal of Counselling and Psychotherapy no. 1976,11(1):28–32.Google Scholar
- Kopp RR: Metaphor therapy: Using client-generated metaphors in psychotherapy. Brunner/Mazel, USA; 1995.Google Scholar
- Kornfield J: After the ecstasy, the laundry: How the heart grows wise on the spiritual path. Bantam Books, USA; 2001.Google Scholar
- Kornfield J, Dass R, Miyuki M: Psychological adjustment is not liberation: A symposium. In Awakening the heart: East/West approaches to psychotherapy and the healing relationship. Edited by: Welwood J. Shambhala Publications, Inc., USA; 1983:33–42.Google Scholar
- Krieglstein Werner J: Compassion: A new philosophy of the other. Rodopi, Amsterdam: New York; 2002.Google Scholar
- Krishan Y: The origin and development of the Bodhisattva doctrine. East and West no. 1984,34(1–3):199–232.Google Scholar
- Kristeller J, James J: "A middle way: Meditation in the treatment of compulsive eating.". In Horizons in Buddhist psychology: Practice, research and theory. Edited by: Maurits G, Kwee T, Gergen KJ, Fusako K. A Taos Institute Publication, Ohio; 2006:85–100.Google Scholar
- Kwee Maurits GT, Gergen KJ, Fusako K: "General introduction: Toward a new Buddhist psychology.". In Horizons in Buddhist psychology: Practice, research and theory. Edited by: Maurits G, Kwee T, Gergen KJ, Fusako K. A Taos Institute Publication, Ohio; 2006:20–26.Google Scholar
- Kwee Maurits GT, Marja T: "A new Buddhist psychology: Moving beyond Theravāda and Mahāyāna.". In Horizons in Buddhist psychology: Practice, research and theory. Edited by: Maurits G, Kwee T, Gergen KJ, Fusako K. A Taos Institute Publication, Ohio; 2006:435–478.Google Scholar
- Paul Marie LÉ: Vimalakīrtinirdeśa (The teaching of Vimalakīrti) 維摩詰經序論. Translated by Guo Zhong Sheng 郭忠生. Di Guang Za Zhi She 諦觀雜誌社, Tainan; 1976/1990.Google Scholar
- Lan Mei 藍梅: Illustrative explanations on minds of loving kindness and compassion 圖解慈悲心. Shaanxi Normal University Publishing House 陝西師範大學出版社, China; 2009.Google Scholar
- Lancaster Lewis R: "The bodhisattva concept: A study Chinese Buddhist canon.". In Bodhisattva doctrine in Buddhism. Edited by: Leslie K. Published for the Canadian Corporation for Studies in Religion /Corporation by Wilfred Laurier University Press, c1981, Waterloo, Ont., Canada; 1981:153–164.Google Scholar
- Laranjeira C: The role of narrative and metaphor in the cancer life story: A theoretical analysis. Medicine, Health Care and Philosophy no. 2013, 16: 469–481.Google Scholar
- Larkin DM, Zahourek RP: Therapeutic storytelling and metaphors. Holistic Nursing Practice no. 1998,2(3):45–54.Google Scholar
- Leighton TD: Bodhisattva archetypes: Classic Buddhist guide to awakening and their modern expression. Arkana, USA; 1998.Google Scholar
- Leung PP, Yu : Autobiographical timeline: A narrative and life story approach in understanding meaning-making in cancer patients. Illness, Crisis and Loss no. 2010,18(2):111–127.Google Scholar
- Li MF, 李明芳 : Study of ethical thoughts of Mahāyāna Buddhism 大乘佛教倫理思想研究. Buddha's Light Publisher 佛光出版社, Taiwan; 1989.Google Scholar
- Lieu TH, 許嬋蕊 : Translation and interpretation of the Vimalakīrti Nirdeśa Sūtra in Vietnam by Venerable Zhi Guang and Venerable Ci Tong 越南智廣、慈通對《維摩詰經》的翻譯與詮釋. Chinese Culture University 中國文化大學, Taiwan; 2004.Google Scholar
- Lin WP, 林文彬 : An exploratory study of the teachings of non-duality in the Vimalakīrti Nirdeśa Sūtra 『維摩詰經』不二法門義理初探. Journal of the Chinese Department, National Chung Hsing University 興大中文學報 no. 1997, 10: 145–158.Google Scholar
- Lin ZY, 林昭益 : Śāriputra's character and role in the Vimalakīrti Nirdeśa Sūtra 舍利弗在《維摩經》中的性格與角色. Chung-Hwa Buddhist Studies 中華佛學研究 no. 1997, 1: 1–21.Google Scholar
- Long D: Buddhist medicines in Chinese literature. Hsi Lai Journal of Humanistic Buddhism no. 2007, 8: 200–221.Google Scholar
- Lopez D, Rockefeller SC: Intoduction. In The Christ and the bodhisattva. Edited by: Jr DL, Rockefeller SC. State University of New York Press, USA; 1987:1–42.Google Scholar
- Lovelady HV: The role of silence in the counselling relationship. Counselling Training Limited, Liverpool; 2006.Google Scholar
- Loy David R: "The lack of self: A Western Buddhist psychology.". In Buddhist theology: Critical reflections by contemporary Buddhist scholars. Edited by: Roger J, John M. Surrey: Curzon Press, UK; 2000:155–172.Google Scholar
- Lukens EP, McFarlane WR: Psychoeducation as evidence-based practice: Considerations for practice, research, and policy. Brief Treatment and Crisis Intervention no. 2004,4(3):205–225.Google Scholar
- Magid B: Ordinary mind: Exploring the common ground of Zen and psychotherapy. Somerville. Wisdom Publications, MA: USA; 2002.Google Scholar
- Manne-Lewis J: Buddhist psychology: A paradigm for the psychology of enlightenment. In Beyond therapy: The impact of Eastern religions on psychological theory and practice. Edited by: Claxton G. Wisdom Publications, England; 1986:123–138.Google Scholar
- Manternach Dean P: Moral dynamics of storytelling: Inviting transformation undated [cited December 13 2013]. 2013.Google Scholar
- Markus H, Nurius P: Possible selves. American Psychologist no. 1986,41(9):954–969.Google Scholar
- Marmar CR: Psychotherapy process research: Progress, dilemmas, and future directions. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology no. 1990,58(3):265–272.Google Scholar
- Maslow AH: A theory of human motivation. Psychological Review no. 1943,50(4):370–396.Google Scholar
- Mather RB: Vimalakīrti and gentry Buddhism. History of Religions no. 1968,8(1):60–73.Google Scholar
- McClary R: Healing the psyche through music, myth, and ritual. Psychology of Aesthetics, Creativity, and the Arts no. 2007,1(3):155–159.Google Scholar
- McFarlane WR, Dixon L, Lukens E, Lucksted A: Family psychoeducation and schizophrenia: A review of the literature. Journal of Marital and Family Therapy no. 2003,29(2):223–245.Google Scholar
- McGoldrick M, Gerson R, Petry S: Genograms : Assessment and intervention. W.W. Norton & Company, New York; 2008.Google Scholar
- McMahon M, Watson M: Story telling: Crafting identities. British Journal of Guidance and Counselling no. 2013,41(3):277–286.Google Scholar
- McRae John R: The Vimalakīrti Sūtra. Numata Centre for Buddhist Translation and Research 2004 [cited February 1 2011]. 2011.Google Scholar
- Miller RA: Yamanoe Okura, a Korean poet in eighth-century Japan. Journal of the American Oriental Society no. 1984,104(4):703–726.Google Scholar
- Mizuno K: Basic Buddhist concepts. Translated by Charles S. Terry and Richard L. Gage. Kosei Publishing Company. Original edition, First published in Japanese in 1965, first English edition in 1987, Tokyo: Tokyo; 2003.Google Scholar
- Morales AT, Sheafor BW, Scot ME: Social work: A profession of many faces. Prentice Hall, USA; 2007.Google Scholar
- Moran Carmen C: "Humor as a moderator of compassion fatigue.". In Treating compassion fatigue. Edited by: Figley CR. Brunner-Routledge, New York; 2002:139–154.Google Scholar
- Myers Charles E, Tollerud TR, Mi-Hee J: "The power of personal storytelling in counsellor education.". Ideas and Research You Can Use: VISTAS 2012 2012,1(Article 19):1–6.Google Scholar
- Nagao Gadjin M: "The Bodhisattva returns to this world.". In Bodhisattva doctrine in Buddhism. Edited by: Leslie K. Published for the Canadian Corporation for Studies in Religion/Corporation by Wilfred Laurier University Press, c1981, Waterloo, Ont., Canada; 1981:61–74.Google Scholar
- Nakamura Hajime中村元: 1997. Loving kindness and compassion 慈悲. Translated by Jiang Zhi Di 江支地. Hai Xiao Publishing Company Limited 海嘯出版事業有限公司. Original edition, Original published in, Hong Kong; 1959.Google Scholar
- Neff KD: Self-compassion: An alternative conceptualization of a healthy attitude toward oneself. Self and Identity no. 2003, 2: 85–101.Google Scholar
- Neff KD: Self-compassion and psychological well-being. Constructivism in the Human Sciences no. 2004,9(2):27–37.Google Scholar
- Neff KD, Kirkpatrick KL, Rude SS: Self-compassion and adaptive psychological functioning. Journal of Research in Personality no. 2007, 41: 139–154.Google Scholar
- Neff KD, Vonk R: Self-compassion versus global self-esteem: Two different ways of relating to oneself. Journal of Personality no. 2009,77(1):23–50.Google Scholar
- Ng CK, 吳智光 : Spirit of counselling in Buddhism 佛教的輔導精神. Asian Journal of Counselling 亞洲輔導學報 no. 1994,3(1 & 2):25–34.Google Scholar
- Oi S: The aspect of gratitude. The Pacific World Journal: Journal of Institute of Buddhist Studies no. 1982,1(1):9–10.Google Scholar
- Parry SJ, Richard GA, Jones : Beyond illusion in the psychotherapeutic enterprise. In Beyond therapy: The impact of Eastern religions on psychological theory and practice. Edited by: Claxton G. Wisdom Publications, England; 1986:175–192.Google Scholar
- Patsiopoulos AT, Buchanan MJ: The practice of self-compassion in counselling: A narrative Inquiry. Professional Psychology: Research and Practice no. 2011,42(4):301–307.Google Scholar
- Patton MQ: Qualitative research and evaluation methods. Sage Publications, Inc., California; 2002.Google Scholar
- Phillips J, Morley J: Introduction. In Imagination and its pathologies. Edited by: Phillips J, Morley J. Massachusetts Iinstitute of Technology Press, USA; 2003:1–18.Google Scholar
- Podvoll E, Fortuna J: Psychotherapy as an expression of the spiritual journey based on the experience of shunyata. In Brilliant sanity: Buddhist approaches to psychotherapy. Edited by: Kaklauskas FJ, Nimanheminda S, Hoffman L, MacAndrew S J. University of the Rockies Press, Colorado; 2008:87–98.Google Scholar
- Ponce DE: Is Buddhism psychotherapy? In Buddhism and peace: Theory and practice. Edited by: Mun C. Jung Bup Sa Buddhist Temple of Hawaii, Hawaii; 2006:331–339.Google Scholar
- Ponlop D: "Forward: Awakening mind’s potential." In Brilliant sanity: Buddhist approaches to psychotherapy, edited by Francis J. Kaklauskas, Susan Nimanheminda, Louise Hoffman and MacAndrew S. Jack, xiii-xvii. University of the Rockies Press, Colorado; 2008.Google Scholar
- Prendergast JJ: Introduction. In The sacred mirror: Non-dual wisdom and psychotherapy. Edited by: Prendergast JJ, Fenner P, Krystal S. Paragon House, Minnesota; 2003:1–22.Google Scholar
- Prendergast JJ: The sacred mirror: Being together. In The sacred mirror: Non-dual wisdom and psychotherapy. Edited by: Prendergast JJ, Fenner P, Krystal S. Paragon House, Minnesota; 2003:89–115.Google Scholar
- Pruett GE: The meaning and end of suffering for Freud and the Buddhist tradition. University Press of America, Inc., USA; 1987.Google Scholar
- Punter D: Metaphor. Routledge, New York; 2007.Google Scholar
- Pye M: Skilful means: A concept in Mahāyāna Buddhism. Routledge, London; 2003.Google Scholar
- Quinn A: A person-centered approach to the treatment of combat veterans with posttraumatic stress disorder. Journal of Humanistic Psychology no. 2008,48(4):458–476.Google Scholar
- Rahula W: The social teachings of the Buddha. Edited by Fred Eppstenier, The path of compassion: Writings on socially engaged Buddhism. Parallax Press, California; 1988.Google Scholar
- Rahula W: What the Buddha taught. Taipei: Torch of Wisdom. Original edition, First published in 1959. The Gordon Fraser Gallery Limited, London; 2001.Google Scholar
- Raskin PM: Rogers’ therapy cases: Views from within and without. In The psychotherapy of Carl Rogers: Cases and commentary. Edited by: Farber BA, Brink DC, Raskin PM. The Guilford Press, USA; 1996:133–141.Google Scholar
- Rawlinson A: The three facets of Buddha-mind. In Beyond therapy: The impact of Eastern religions on psychological theory and practice. Edited by: Claxton G. Wisdom Publications, England; 1986:138–152.Google Scholar
- Ray C: Western psychology and Buddhist teachings: Convergences and divergences. In Beyond therapy: The impact of Eastern religions on psychological theory and practice. Edited by: Claxton G. Wisdom Publications, England; 1986:17–29.Google Scholar
- Reichenbach BR: The law of karma: A philosophical study. University of Hawaii Press, USA; 1990.Google Scholar
- Riessman F: The “helper” therapy principle. Journal of the National Association of Social Work no. 1965,10(2):27–32.Google Scholar
- Rogers CR: Significant aspects of client-centred therapy. American Psychologist no. 1946, 1: 415–422.Google Scholar
- Rogers CR: Some observations on the organization of personality. American Psychologist no. 1947, 2: 358–368.Google Scholar
- Rogers CR: The necessary and sufficient conditions of therapeutic personality change. Journal of Consulting Psychology no. 1957, 21: 95–103.Google Scholar
- Rogers CR: A theory of therapy, personality, and interpersonal relationships, as developed in the client-centred framework. In Psychology: A study of a science, Study I, Conceptual and systematic. Edited by: Koch S. McGraw-Hill Book Company, Inc., USA; 1959:184–256.Google Scholar
- Rogers CR: "Toward a Science of the person." In Behaviorism and phenomenology: Contrasting bases for modern psychology, edited by T. W.Wann. The Unviersity of Chicago Press, Chicago; 1964.Google Scholar
- Rogers CR, Nelson A: The power of the powerless. In Carl Rogers on personal power. Edited by: Rogers C. Delacorte Press, New York; 1977:186–204.Google Scholar
- Rogers R: Metaphor: A psychoanalytic view. University of California Press, USA; 1978.Google Scholar
- Roshi JS: Where is the self? In Awakening the heart: East/West approaches to psychotherapy and the healing relationship. Edited by: Welwood J. Shambhala Publications, Inc., USA; 1983:70–74.Google Scholar
- Rubin JB: Deepening psychoanalytic listening: The marriage of Buddha and Freud. The American Journal of Psychoanalysis no. 2009, 69: 93–105.Google Scholar
- Safren SA, Hollander G, Hart TA, Heimberg RG: Cognitive-behavioural therapy with lesbian, gay, and bisexual youth. Cognitive and Behavioural Practice no. 2001, 8: 215–223.Google Scholar
- Salzberg S: "Foreward." In The mindful path to self-compassion: Freeing yourself from destructive thoughts and emotions, edited by Christopher K. Germer, ix-x. The Guilford Press, New York; 2009.Google Scholar
- Salzberg S: The force of kindness: Change your Life with love and compassion. Sounds True, Inc., Canada; 2010.Google Scholar
- Sasaki LV: The aspect of life of meaning and growth. The Pacific World Journal: Journal of Institute of Buddhist Studies no. 1982,1(1):11–12.Google Scholar
- Schneider KJ, Tong B: Existentialism, Taoism, and Buddhism: Two views. In Existential psychology East–west. Edited by: Hoffman L, Yang M, Kaklauskas FJ, Chan A. University of the Rockies Press, USA; 2009:165–176.Google Scholar
- Schroeder JW: Skillful means: The heart of Buddhist compassion. University of Hawai'i Press, USA; 2001.Google Scholar
- Schwabenland C: Metaphor and dialectic in managing diversity. Palgrave Macmillan, New York; 2012.Google Scholar
- Sheng-yen Master 聖嚴法師: Practice in the secular world: Six lectures on the Vimalakīrti Nirdeśa Sūtra 修行在紅塵:維摩經六講. Dharma Drum Corporation 法鼓山文化事業有限公司, Taiwan; 1988.Google Scholar
- Shi XT, 釋心田 : Illustrative explanations on the Vimalakīrti Nirdeśa Sūtra 圖解維摩詰經. Zijincheng Publishing Company 紫禁城出版社, China; 2009.Google Scholar
- Silverberg F: Resonance and exchange in contemplative psychotherapy. In Brilliant sanity: Buddhist approaches to psychotherapy. Edited by: Kaklauskas FJ, Nimanheminda S, Hoffman L, MacAndrew S J. University of the Rockies Press, USA; 2008:239–257.Google Scholar
- Slater P: "The relevance of the Bodhisattva concept for today.". In Bodhisattva doctrine in Buddhism. Edited by: Leslie K. Published for the Canadian Corporation for Studies in Religion/Corporation by Wilfred Laurier University Press, c1981, Waterloo, Ont., Canada; 1981:1–15.Google Scholar
- Smith JA, Flowers P, Larkin M: Interpretative phenomenological analysis: Theory, method and research. SAGE Publications Limited, UK; 2009.Google Scholar
- Snow MS, Ouzts R, Martin EE, Helm H: Creative metaphors of life experiences seen in play therapy. VISTAS Online no. Article 2005, 12: 63–65.Google Scholar
- Solberg H, Nysether GE, Steinsbekk A: Patients’ experiences with metaphors in a solution-focused approach to improve self-management skills: A qualitative study. Scandinavian Journal of Public Health no. 2012, 40: 398–401.Google Scholar
- Soothill WE: The three religions of China: Lectures delivered at Oxford. Hodder and Stoughton, London; 1913.Google Scholar
- Stone D: Wounded healing: Exploring the circle of compassion in the helping relationship. The Humanistic Psychologist no. 2008, 36: 45–51.Google Scholar
- Storhoff G, Whalen-Bridge J: Introduction: American Buddhism as a way of life. In American Buddhism as a way of life. Edited by: Storhoff G, Whalen-Bridge J. State University of New York Press, USA; 2010:1–10.Google Scholar
- Sugamura G, Scott W: "Conjoining paradigms: A dissolution-oriented approach to psychotherapy.". In Horizons in Buddhist psychology: Practice, research and theory. Edited by: Maurits G, Kwee T, Gergen KJ, Fusako K. A Taos Institute Publication, Ohio; 2006:379–397.Google Scholar
- Sugioka T: The metaphor of “ocean” in Shinran. Pacific World: Journal of the Institute of Buddhist Studies no. 2009,3(11):219–228.Google Scholar
- Suzuki Beatrice L: Mahāyāna Buddhism. George Allen & Unwin. Original edition, Original published 1938, London; 1938/1981a.Google Scholar
- Suzuki Daisetz T: "Introduction.". In Mahāyāna Buddhism. Edited by: Beatrice Lane S. George Allen & Unwin, London; 1938/1981b:1–17.Google Scholar
- Suzuki DT, Fromm E, DeMartino R: Zen Buddhism and psychoanalysis. Grove Press Inc., New York; 1963.Google Scholar
- Szkredka S: Reason as employed by the Buddha: Its originality and mystical foundations. Hsi Lai Journal of Humanistic Buddhism no. 2007, 8: 181–200.Google Scholar
- Tada K: The aspect of great compassion. The Pacific World Journal: Journal of Institute of Buddhist Studies no. 1982,1(1):6–7.Google Scholar
- Taels J: Humour as practical wisdom. In Humour and religion: Challenges and ambiguities. Edited by: Geybels H, Van Herck W. Continuum, New York; 2011:22–34.Google Scholar
- Tam SW, 談錫永 : A study of Vajrayāna emerged in the Vimalakīrti Nirdeśa Sūtra 維摩經旨密義初探. Nei Ming 內明 no. 1995,284(November):3–18.Google Scholar
- Teasdale JD, Segal Z, Mark J, Williams G: How does cognitive therapy prevent depressive relapse and why should attentional control (mindfulness) training help? Behaviour Research Therapy no. 1995,33(1):25–39.Google Scholar
- Thigpen ML, Beauclair TJ, Keiser GM, Guevara M, Mestad R: Cognitive behavioural treatment: A review and discussion for corrections professionals. U.S. Department of Justice, National Institute of Corrections, USA; 2007.Google Scholar
- Thompson BL, Waltz J: Mindfulness and experiential avoidance as predictors of posttraumatic stress disorder avoidance symptom severity. Journal of Anxiety Disorders no. 2010, 24: 409–415.Google Scholar
- Thubten CV: Dealing with life's issues, working with anger: A Buddhist perspective. The Corporate Body of the Buddha Educational Foundation, Taiwan; 2008.Google Scholar
- Thurman R: Inner revolution: Life liberty, and the pursuit of real happiness. Riverhead Books, New York; 1998.Google Scholar
- Thurman RAF: Foreward. In In A call to compassion: Bringing Buddhist practices of the heart into the soul of psychology, edited by Aura Glaser, xi-xii. Nicolas-Hays, Inc., USA; 2005.Google Scholar
- Townsend P, Kaklauskas FJ: Therapist subjectivity in contemplative psychotherapy. In Brilliant sanity: Buddhist approaches to psychotherapy. Edited by: Kaklauskas FJ, Nimanheminda S, Hoffman L, MacAndrew S J. University of the Rockies Press, Colorado; 2008:39–64.Google Scholar
- Trungpa C: Becoming a full human being. In Awakening the heart: East/west approaches to psychotherapy and the healing relationship. Edited by: Welwood J. Shambhala Publications, Inc., USA; 1983:126–131.Google Scholar
- Herck V, Walter : Humour, religion and vulnerability. In Humour and religion: Challenges and ambiguities. Edited by: Geybels H, Van Herck W. Continuum, New York; 2011:191–203.Google Scholar
- Walker R: A discipline of inquisitiveness: The body-speech-mind approach to contemplative supervision. In Brilliant sanity: Buddhist approaches to psychotherapy. Edited by: Kaklauskas FJ, Nimanheminda S, Hoffman L, MacAndrew S J. University of the Rockies Press, Colorado; 2008:175–194.Google Scholar
- Wallace BA: Boundless heart: The four immeasurables. Edited by Zara Houshmand. Snow Lion Publications, Ithaca, New York; 1999.Google Scholar
- Wallace BA: The four immeasurables: Practices to open the heart. Snow Lion Publications, New York; 2010.Google Scholar
- Wallace BA, Shapiro SL: Mental balance and well-being: Building bridges between Buddhism and Western psychology. American Psychologist no. 2006,61(7):690–701.Google Scholar
- Walley MR: Applications of Buddhism in mental health care. In Beyond therapy: The impact of Eastern religions on psychological theory and practice. Edited by: Claxton G. Wisdom Publications, England; 1986:195–216.Google Scholar
- Walsh T: The solution-focused helper: Ethics and practice in health and social care. Open University Press, UK; 2010.Google Scholar
- The Vimalakīrti Sūtra. Columbia University Press, New York; 1997.Google Scholar
- Watson G: The resonance of emptiness: A Buddhist inspiration for a contemporary psychotherapy. Curzon, UK; 1998.Google Scholar
- Welwood J: Dancing with form and emptiness in intimate relationship. In The sacred mirror: Nondual wisdom and psychotherapy. Edited by: Prendergast JJ, Fenner P, Krystal S. Paragon House, USA; 2003:290–302.Google Scholar
- Welwood J: On psychology and meditation. In Awakening the heart: East/west approaches to psychotherapy and the healing relationship. Edited by: Welwood J. Shambhala Publications, Inc., USA; 1983:43–54.Google Scholar
- Whipps JD: Touched by suffering: American pragmatism and engaged Buddhism. In American Buddhism as a way of life. Edited by: Storhoff G, Whalen-Bridge J. State Unviersity of New York Press, USA; 2010:101–123.Google Scholar
- Wicks R: Arthur Schopenhauer. Standard of Encyclopedia of Philosophy 2007 [cited December 25 2010]. 2007.Google Scholar
- Wilkins J, Eisenbraun AJ: Humor theories and the physiological benefits of laughter. Holistic Nursing Practice no. 2009,23(6):349–354.Google Scholar
- Williams JG, Stark SK, Foster EE: Start today or the very last day? The relationships among self-compassion, motivation, and procrastination. American Journal of Psychological Research no. 2008,4(1):37–44.Google Scholar
- Williams P: Altruism and reality: Studies in the philosophy of the Bodhicaryāvatāra. Curzon Press, UK; 1998.Google Scholar
- Witztum E, van der Hart O, Friedman B: The use of metaphors in psychotherapy. Journal of Contemporary Psychotherapy no. 1988,18(4):270–290.Google Scholar
- Wray E, Rosenfield C, Bailey D, Wray J: Ten lives of the Buddha: Siamese temple paintings and Jataka tales. Weatherhill, Inc., USA; 1979.Google Scholar
- Wray I: Buddhism and psychotherapy: A Buddhist perspective. In Beyond therapy: The impact of Eastern religions on psychological theory and practice. Edited by: Claxton G. Wisdom Publications, England; 1986:155–172.Google Scholar
- Wright DS: The six perfections: Buddhism and the cultivation of character. Oxford University Press, New York; 2009.Google Scholar
- Yalom ID: Existential psychotherapy. Basic Books, USA; 1980.Google Scholar
- Yamaguchi Susumu山口益: History of prajñā thought 般若思想史. Translated by Xiao Ping 肖平 and Yang Jin Ping 楊金萍. Shanghai Chinese Classics Publishing House 上海古籍出版社, China; 1999/2006.Google Scholar
- Yin-Shun Master 印順導師: Origin of Mahāyāna Buddhism 大乘佛教導源. In Development of Mahāyāna Buddhism 大乘佛教之發展. Edited by: Tao ZM, 張曼濤. Mahāyāna Culture Publishing 大乘文化出版社, Taipei; 1979:1–15.Google Scholar
- You HJ, 尤惠貞 : Philosophy of Tiantai and praxis of Buddhism 天臺哲學與佛教實踐. Nanhua University 南華大學, Taiwan; 1999.Google Scholar
- Young-Eisendrath P: The transformation of human suffering: A perspective from psychotherapy and Buddhism. Psychoanalytic Inquiry no. 2008, 28: 541–549.Google Scholar
- Zheng JD, 鄭金德 : Principles of modern Buddhism 現代佛學原理. Dong Da Book Company 東大圖書公司, Taipei; 1986.Google Scholar
- Zopa LR: Bodhisattva attitude: How to dedicate your life to others. Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive, Boston; 2012.Google Scholar
This article is published under license to BioMed Central Ltd. This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly credited.